Advertisement
ArticleAging Free access | 10.1172/JCI17667
1Baylor University Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA2 Children’s Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA3 Karl-Franzens University, Graz, Austria
Address correspondence to: John S. Fordtran, Baylor University Medical Center, 3500 Gaston Avenue, Dallas, Texas 75246, USA. Phone: (214) 820-2672; Fax: (214) 820-4837; E-mail: johnfo@baylorhealth.edu.
Find articles by Russo, M. in: PubMed | Google Scholar
1Baylor University Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA2 Children’s Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA3 Karl-Franzens University, Graz, Austria
Address correspondence to: John S. Fordtran, Baylor University Medical Center, 3500 Gaston Avenue, Dallas, Texas 75246, USA. Phone: (214) 820-2672; Fax: (214) 820-4837; E-mail: johnfo@baylorhealth.edu.
Find articles by Högenauer, C. in: PubMed | Google Scholar
1Baylor University Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA2 Children’s Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA3 Karl-Franzens University, Graz, Austria
Address correspondence to: John S. Fordtran, Baylor University Medical Center, 3500 Gaston Avenue, Dallas, Texas 75246, USA. Phone: (214) 820-2672; Fax: (214) 820-4837; E-mail: johnfo@baylorhealth.edu.
Find articles by Coates, S. in: PubMed | Google Scholar
1Baylor University Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA2 Children’s Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA3 Karl-Franzens University, Graz, Austria
Address correspondence to: John S. Fordtran, Baylor University Medical Center, 3500 Gaston Avenue, Dallas, Texas 75246, USA. Phone: (214) 820-2672; Fax: (214) 820-4837; E-mail: johnfo@baylorhealth.edu.
Find articles by Santa Ana, C. in: PubMed | Google Scholar
1Baylor University Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA2 Children’s Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA3 Karl-Franzens University, Graz, Austria
Address correspondence to: John S. Fordtran, Baylor University Medical Center, 3500 Gaston Avenue, Dallas, Texas 75246, USA. Phone: (214) 820-2672; Fax: (214) 820-4837; E-mail: johnfo@baylorhealth.edu.
Find articles by Porter, J. in: PubMed | Google Scholar
1Baylor University Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA2 Children’s Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA3 Karl-Franzens University, Graz, Austria
Address correspondence to: John S. Fordtran, Baylor University Medical Center, 3500 Gaston Avenue, Dallas, Texas 75246, USA. Phone: (214) 820-2672; Fax: (214) 820-4837; E-mail: johnfo@baylorhealth.edu.
Find articles by Rosenblatt, R. in: PubMed | Google Scholar
1Baylor University Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA2 Children’s Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA3 Karl-Franzens University, Graz, Austria
Address correspondence to: John S. Fordtran, Baylor University Medical Center, 3500 Gaston Avenue, Dallas, Texas 75246, USA. Phone: (214) 820-2672; Fax: (214) 820-4837; E-mail: johnfo@baylorhealth.edu.
Find articles by Emmett, M. in: PubMed | Google Scholar
1Baylor University Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA2 Children’s Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA3 Karl-Franzens University, Graz, Austria
Address correspondence to: John S. Fordtran, Baylor University Medical Center, 3500 Gaston Avenue, Dallas, Texas 75246, USA. Phone: (214) 820-2672; Fax: (214) 820-4837; E-mail: johnfo@baylorhealth.edu.
Find articles by Fordtran, J. in: PubMed | Google Scholar
Published July 1, 2003 - More info
Due to genetic defects in apical membrane chloride channels, the cystic fibrosis (CF) intestine does not secrete chloride normally. Depressed chloride secretion leaves CF intestinal absorptive processes unopposed, which results in net fluid hyperabsorption, dehydration of intestinal contents, and a propensity to inspissated intestinal obstruction. This theory is based primarily on in vitro studies of jejunal mucosa. To determine if CF patients actually hyperabsorb fluid in vivo, we measured electrolyte and water absorption during steady-state perfusion of the jejunum. As expected, chloride secretion was abnormally low in CF, but surprisingly, there was no net hyperabsorption of sodium or water during perfusion of a balanced electrolyte solution. This suggested that fluid absorption processes are reduced in CF jejunum, and further studies revealed that this was due to a marked depression of passive chloride absorption. Although Na+-glucose cotransport was normal in the CF jejunum, absence of passive chloride absorption completely blocked glucose-stimulated net sodium absorption and reduced glucose-stimulated water absorption 66%. This chloride absorptive abnormality acts in physiological opposition to the classic chloride secretory defect in the CF intestine. By increasing the fluidity of intraluminal contents, absence of passive chloride absorption may reduce the incidence and severity of intestinal disease in patients with CF.
Cystic fibrosis (CF) is caused by mutations in the CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene. CFTR functions as a chloride channel in apical or basal membranes of epithelial cells, and, in addition, it regulates the activity of other ion channels and ion transport carriers (1, 2). The clinical manifestations of CF are believed to be due primarily to defects in epithelial cell ion transport in organs such as the lung, pancreas, and intestine (3).
CF intestinal disease is believed to result from hyperabsorption of water from the intestinal lumen. It is well established that the CF intestine does not secrete chloride normally, and some (4–7), but not other (8–11), investigators have reported increased absorption of sodium and/or glucose by CF intestine. Since intestinal water movement is determined by net movement of solute, either decreased chloride secretion or increased sodium or glucose absorption would result in hyperabsorption of water. This, in turn, may produce dehydration and inspissation of intestinal contents, manifested clinically as meconium ileus in newborns or distal intestinal obstruction syndrome (meconium ileus equivalent) in children and adults. Most experimental data supporting the fluid hyperabsorption theory have been obtained in vitro under short-circuit conditions with jejunum of humans or mice (5–9, 11–13). This technique, however, eliminates passive ion movement in response to electrochemical gradients, which is required for net ion transport under in vivo conditions, and it does not allow measurement of net water absorption. It is not known, therefore, if the ion transport abnormalities identified in CF jejunum by in vitro studies would actually result in net hyperabsorption of electrolytes and water in vivo. Although two in vivo studies in humans confirmed reduced active chloride secretion by CF jejunum, both employed test solutions that purposely prevented normal absorptive processes in order to measure the magnitude of active chloride secretion (14, 15).
To further evaluate the hyperabsorption hypothesis, we measured jejunal electrolyte and water absorption in 12 adult CF patients in vivo. Although defective chloride secretion was confirmed, CF patients did not hyperabsorb electrolytes or water during perfusion of a physiological electrolyte solution. This indicated that fluid absorptive processes by CF jejunum were inhibited by some unknown mechanism. Further studies revealed that this inhibition is due to absence of passive chloride absorption. This abnormality in CF jejunum virtually eliminates glucose-stimulated sodium absorption, and by retarding jejunal water absorption it acts in physiological opposition to the classic CF chloride secretory defect.
The Institutional Review Board for Human Protection at Baylor University Medical Center approved this research. Informed consent was obtained, and the subjects were paid a fee for their participation. Normal subjects and patients with CF were studied contemporaneously. Blood leukocytes or buccal cells from CF patients were assayed for 87 CFTR mutations (Genzyme Genetics, Framingham, Massachusetts, USA). Each patient had the approval of his or her primary care pulmonologist before engaging in these experiments. Normal volunteers were seminary students and their spouses and employees of Baylor Hospital.
Steady-state perfusion technique. Absorption and secretion were measured by intubation of the jejunum with a triple-lumen tube and constant perfusion of the jejunal lumen with isotonic test solutions. The test solutions contained a nonabsorbable volume marker, polyethylene glycol (PEG; MW 3350). Solutions were infused at a rate of 10 ml/min through the infusion aperture of the tube, the position of which was verified by fluoroscopy to be located at the ligament of Treitz. After steady-state conditions were obtained, samples of jejunal perfusate were collected at a constant rate (1.5 ml/min) for 1 hour from apertures in the tube located 10 and 40 cm distal to the infusion aperture. Using previously reported analytical methods and standard nonabsorbable marker equations, solute and water absorption rates by the 30-cm segment of proximal jejunum (located between the two sampling sites) were measured (16, 17).
Potential difference. Potential difference (PD) was continuously recorded between a flowing intraluminal electrode and a subcutaneous reference electrode (18). The reference electrode consisted of saline in a Kendall Medicut IV Cannula (Tyco Healthcare UK Ltd., Ballymoney, United Kingdom) inserted into the subcutaneous tissue of the dorsal aspect of the forearm. This subcutaneous reference and the flowing luminal catheter were connected by 3 M KCl agar bridges and calomel half-cells to the input terminals of a battery-powered electrometer (model 610C; Keithley Instruments Inc., Cleveland, Ohio, USA), and the output was displayed on a chart recorder (Model BD 111/112; Kipp & Zonen BV, Delft, The Netherlands).
Perfused test solutions. Five separate experiments involving infusion of different test solutions were performed. All solutions contained PEG, 2 g/l, and were isotonic to plasma. The solute composition of test solutions is expressed as millimoles per liter. The balanced electrolyte solution contained Na+ 140, Cl– 92, HCO3– 45, K+ 4, SO42– 3.5, and mannitol 23.5. To measure gradient-generated passive chloride absorption, five different solutions were infused, each containing Na+ 140 and K+ 4; Cl– ranged from 104 to 140, with a reciprocal decrease in SO42– and mannitol concentrations sufficient to maintain anion/cation balance and isotonicity. The glucose-NaCl solution contained glucose 70, Na+ 110, Cl– 115, and K+ 5. The two solutions used to measure diffusion potential contained Cl– 4, K+ 4, mannitol 280; and Na+ 145, Cl– 4, K+ 4, SO42– 72.5, and mannitol 100. The solution to measure the L-xylose/urea diffusion ratio was Na+ 90, Cl– 90, mannitol 45, urea 39, and L-xylose 18.
Statistics. Statistical significance of differences was assessed by a t test. P values less than 0.05 were considered statistically significant.
Patient demographics. Eleven of the 12 CF patients have defined mutations on both CFTR alleles (Table 1). All patients have chronic sinopulmonary infections and steatorrhea due to pancreatic insufficiency. Five of the patients had meconium ileus as newborns. Patients 4 and 6 had single episodes of possible distal intestinal obstruction syndrome, although x-ray studies failed to reveal an obstruction. No differences were detected between the eight patients who are homozygous for ΔF508 mutations and the four patients with other mutations, or between patients with and without a history of meconium ileus. The functional status of the patients is provided in the table. Performance of these experiments was not associated with any deleterious effects on patient health.
CF patients do not hyperabsorb electrolytes and water during perfusion of a balanced electrolyte solution in vivo. The generally accepted mechanisms for jejunal absorption of a balanced electrolyte solution (19, 20) are summarized in the top left diagram of Figure 1. Na+ is absorbed across the apical membrane in exchange for H+. The secreted H+ ions react with and dissipate luminal HCO3–. Na+ is pumped out of the cell across the basolateral membrane, accompanied by HCO3– derived from intracellular H2CO3. This absorptive mechanism does not generate an electrical PD favoring passive chloride absorption. However, water absorption resulting from absorption of NaHCO3 causes the concentration of luminal chloride to rise, ultimately to 140 mEq/l when luminal bicarbonate is fully dissipated. In normal subjects, this chloride-concentration gradient results in passive Cl– absorption via the tight-junction paracellular pathway; this is followed by additional Na+ absorption to maintain electrical balance, and this passive NaCl absorption promotes further water absorption. In opposition to these absorptive mechanisms, the jejunum simultaneously secretes chloride via apical membrane CFTR channels (19, 20). Net water movement depends upon the relative rates of electrolyte absorption versus electrolyte secretion. Since chloride secretion is reduced in CF jejunum (15), increased net absorption would be expected.
Conventional models of normal electrolyte absorption by the human jejunum and a possible explanation for chloride malabsorption in cystic fibrosis. The illustrations represent epithelial cells and the adjacent tight-junction paracellular pathways. The apical membrane is on the left and the basolateral membrane is on the right side of each cell. A Na+, K+-ATPase on the basolateral membrane pumps Na+ out of the cell, into the subepithelial space. For convenience, water absorption is depicted as occurring exclusively through paracellular spaces, although it may also occur through the cell. Since these are models of electrolyte absorption, the transporters and channels that mediate active chloride secretion are not depicted. Detailed explanations of the models for normal absorption and a proposed explanation for passive chloride malabsorption in cystic fibrosis are provided within the Results and Discussion sections, respectively.
During perfusion of a balanced electrolyte solution, net absorption of sodium and water was at a low-normal level in CF patients (Figure 2), rather than high, as predicted. Lower than expected absorption by CF jejunum cannot be attributed to reduced Na+/H+ exchange because bicarbonate absorption was perfectly normal, and bicarbonate absorption is a direct measure of jejunal Na+/H+ exchange (21). CF patients have reduced active chloride secretion (15); therefore, if they absorb chloride normally, net chloride absorption rate should be supranormal. Net chloride absorption was not increased, however, suggesting that chloride absorption is depressed in CF jejunum.
Net absorption and secretion during perfusion of a balanced electrolyte solution. Values are mean ± SEM. Minus signs denote net absorption (disappearance from the lumen), and plus signs denote net secretion (gain to the lumen). Black bars denote normal control subjects, n = 5, and white bars denote CF patients, n = 5. There was no statistically significant difference between controls and CF patients.
Absence of chloride absorption in response to chloride-concentration gradients. The jejunum was perfused with test solutions designed to provide a progressive increase in the chloride-concentration gradient between lumen and plasma. The absence of bicarbonate from these solutions removes a luminal buffer for secreted hydrogen ions, inhibiting Na+/H+ exchange (16, 22). Furthermore, normal human jejunum does not actively absorb chloride (17, 22–24). Under these conditions, therefore, net chloride transport represents the balance between gradient-generated passive chloride absorption and CFTR-mediated active chloride secretion.
In normal subjects, the regression line indicated a chloride secretion rate of 7 mEq/h/30 cm in the absence of a chloride-concentration gradient (i.e., when luminal chloride concentration was 104 mEq/l) (Figure 3). As luminal chloride concentration was raised above the concentration of chloride in plasma, passive chloride absorption offset CFTR-mediated chloride secretion. When luminal chloride concentration exceeded 125 mEq/l, net chloride absorption was observed.
Net chloride absorption in response to chloride-concentration gradients. Results in normal subjects are shown on the left, and results in CF patients are shown on the right. Minus signs denote net absorption (disappearance from the lumen), and plus signs denote net secretion (gain to the lumen). Linear regression for results in normal controls, r = 0.73, P < 0.001. Linear regression for results in CF patients, r = 0.16, P = 0.52. The difference in the linear regression lines was statistically significant (P < 0.001). In data not shown in the figure, PD was lower in CF patients than in normal subjects (–0.1 ± 0.04 mV versus –1.8 ± 0.2 mV, respectively; P = 0.02), in accord with reduced electrogenic chloride secretion by CF jejunum, and PD was similar at all studied levels of luminal chloride concentrations in both groups. Net sodium transport was virtually identical to net chloride transport.
In CF patients, the regression line indicated that chloride secretion, in the absence of a chloride-concentration gradient between plasma and lumen, was lower than normal. This is consistent with reduced CFTR-mediated chloride secretion (15). CF patients, however, continued to secrete chloride even with luminal chloride concentrations as high as 135–140 mEq/l (Figure 3). Therefore, passive gradient-generated chloride absorption by CF jejunum was absent.
Absence of net NaCl absorption by CF jejunum in response to Na+-glucose cotransport. As summarized in the bottom left diagram of Figure 1, Na+-glucose cotransport causes Na+ to move across the apical membrane, from jejunal lumen into the cell, and a basolateral ATPase pump moves Na+ out of the cell into the subepithelial space. Since Na+ is not accompanied across the basolateral membrane with an anion, this process generates an electrical potential difference between lumen and subepithelial space. In response to this potential, normal subjects absorb Cl– passively via the tight-junction paracellular pathway, allowing net absorption of NaCl. We hypothesized that CF jejunum would not absorb chloride in response to the electrical gradient generated by the Na+-glucose cotransport. To test this hypothesis, we perfused the jejunum with a glucose-NaCl solution. Glucose was absorbed at the same rate in normal subjects and CF patients, and PD was lumen negative in both groups (Figure 4), indicating normal electrogenic Na+-glucose cotransport by CF jejunum. In normal jejunum, Na+-glucose cotransport was associated with high rates of net sodium, chloride, and water absorption. In contrast, Na+-glucose cotransport in CF patients was associated with essentially zero net sodium and chloride absorption, and water absorption was only one-third as great as in normal subjects.
Net absorption and PD during perfusion of a glucose-NaCl solution. Black bars denote values in normal subjects, n = 5; white bars denote values in CF patients, n = 5. Minus signs denote net absorption of solutes and water or lumen-negative PD. Units for glucose are millimoles per hour per 30 cm; units for PD are in millivolts; units for sodium and chloride are milliequivalents per hour per 30 cm; and units for water are milliliters per hour per 30 cm. P values for differences between normal and CF are as follows: glucose, P = 0.42; PD, P = 0.053; sodium, P = 0.002; chloride, P = 0.002; water, P = 0.02.
Diffusion potentials show reduced permeability of CF jejunum to chloride. Perfusion solutions that create ion concentration gradients across the mucosa generate PDs that reflect the relative permeability of an epithelium to different ions (25–27). Perfusing the jejunum with isotonic mannitol creates concentration gradients favoring passive diffusion of sodium and chloride from plasma to lumen (140 mEq/l gradient for sodium and 100 mEq/l gradient for chloride). Since the gradients were not equal, PD cannot precisely determine the relative permeability of sodium and chloride in either normal or CF subjects. Differences in PD between normal and CF subjects, however, reflect differences in the ratio of chloride-to-sodium permeability. PD was more lumen-side positive in CF patients than in normal subjects, indicating a lower Cl–/Na+ permeability ratio in CF (Figure 5).
PD during jejunal perfusion of mannitol and sodium sulfate solutions. Minus signs denote a lumen-negative PD, plus signs denote a lumen-positive PD. Black bars denote values in normal control subjects, n = 6; white bars denote values in CF patients, n = 6. P values for differences between normal and CF are as follows: mannitol, P = 0.001; Na2SO4, P = 0.032.
Perfusing the jejunum with isotonic sodium sulfate establishes gradients for sulfate diffusion from lumen to plasma (gradient 145 mEq/l) and chloride diffusion from plasma to lumen (gradient 100 mEq/l). PD was more lumen positive in CF patients than in normal subjects, indicating that the Cl–/SO42– permeability ratio is lower in CF than in normal subjects.
The ratio of l-xylose and urea diffusion coefficients is normal in CF jejunum. L-xylose has a molecular radius of 3.4 Å, and urea has a molecular radius of 2.4 Å. These uncharged water-soluble solutes are absorbed passively by the jejunum, presumably via tight junctions (28, 29). The ratio of their diffusion coefficients is a reflection of the size of the aqueous diffusion channels through which the solutes are absorbed (29, 30). A ratio approaching 1.0 would indicate little discrimination between the two solutes by the diffusion channels, meaning that the size of the channels is large in relation to the size of the solutes. A ratio approaching zero would indicate a high degree of discrimination and relatively small diffusion channels. Methods for calculating the diffusion ratio of these solutes have been published previously (29). We found that the L-xylose/urea diffusion coefficient ratio was 0.30 ± 0.03 in normal subjects and 0.35 ± 0.03 in CF patients (P = 0.299). These results indicate that the size of the aqueous channels, through which small uncharged solutes diffuse, is similar in normal and CF jejunum.
The human jejunum does not exhibit any evidence of active chloride absorption (17, 22–24), but it readily absorbs chloride passively in vivo in response to electrochemical gradients (17, 22). The jejunal capacity for passive chloride absorption in vivo is at least 16 mEq/h/30 cm (see Figure 4). This matches or exceeds the rate of jejunal chloride secretion in response to a prostaglandin E1 agonist (16.4 mEq/h/30 cm), cholera toxin (14.6 mEq/h/30 cm), or infection with Vibrio cholerae (10 mEq/h/30 cm) (15, 31, 32). The present research has revealed a striking chloride malabsorption by the jejunum of adult patients with CF. We will discuss three possible explanations for this finding.
Defects in an undiscovered Cl–/HCO3– exchanger. If the human jejunum contained a Cl–/HCO3– exchanger, such as that in the human ileum (19, 20, 33), a defect in this exchange could explain chloride malabsorption under some conditions (34). Cl–/HCO3– exchange in the jejunum would be electrically neutral, however, and this would not provide net transmucosal absorption of anions to balance sodium ions absorbed in response to electrogenic Na+-glucose cotransport. Therefore, even if the normal jejunum contained a previously undetected Cl–/HCO3– exchanger, a defect in this exchange could not explain absent NaCl absorption in CF patients during perfusion of a glucose-NaCl solution. In addition, deletion of a hypothetical Cl–/HCO3– exchanger could not explain abnormalities in diffusion potentials that were observed in CF patients. These diffusion potential abnormalities are, however, consistent with reduced passive chloride movement through either CFTR channels or through the paracellular tight-junction pathway.
Reduced passive chloride absorption through CFTR channels. Electrochemical gradients across the apical membranes of epithelial cells determine the direction of chloride movement through CFTR channels (19, 20). In the intestine, these gradients are generally oriented in a secretory direction, so that chloride moves out of intestinal cells into the intestinal lumen. The majority of CFTR-containing cells in intestinal mucosa are located in crypts, and these cells are believed to be the main source of chloride secretion in patients with secretory diarrhea. Most epithelial cells of human jejunal villi also express CFTR, albeit in amounts much less than are present in crypts (35). In addition, a small subpopulation (less than 3%) of jejunal villous cells express CFTR in large amounts (35, 36). If the electrochemical gradient across the apical membranes of CFTR-containing villous cells favored chloride absorption, these CFTR channels could mediate normal passive chloride absorption. Apical membrane CFTR channels in the eccrine sweat gland have an analogous bidirectional role, mediating chloride secretion in the secretory tubule and chloride absorption in the absorptive duct (37). If villous CFTR-containing cells did mediate passive absorption of chloride in normal subjects, then abnormal CFTR chloride channels in villous cells could explain reduced passive chloride absorption in patients with CF. This model is attractive because a single defective molecular mechanism could then account for both reduced chloride secretion and reduced chloride absorption.
Three aspects of this hypothesis are problematic, however. First, CFTR channels mediating chloride secretion are usually closed or nearly closed in the basal state. If villous CFTR-containing cells mediated passive chloride absorption at the high rates observed in this study (Figure 4), their apical chloride channels would need to be open during perfusion of glucose solutions, and apical chloride channels of CFTR-containing cells that mediate secretion would need to be less open or closed. Second, passive chloride absorption and secretion in the normal jejunum is markedly influenced by the direction and magnitude of bulk water flow across the mucosa, even when luminal chloride concentration is constant at all levels of water flow (17). This solvent drag effect indicates that chloride and water traverse the mucosa through the same channels or pores. Since CFTR channels apparently do not transport water (38), it is difficult to explain the solvent drag effect if passive chloride absorption/secretion in normal jejunum occurs mainly through CFTR channels. Third, if the paracellular shunt pathway mediates a substantial fraction of passive chloride absorption, as is generally believed, a reduction in passive chloride absorption by villous CFTR cells could not explain the total absence of passive chloride absorption that we observed in CF jejunum.
Reduced passive chloride absorption through the paracellular shunt. Measurement of voltage-clamped ion fluxes and electrically equivalent circuit analysis have shown that passive sodium and chloride movement across in vitro small intestinal mucosa of laboratory animals occurs almost exclusively through leaky tight junctions in the paracellular shunt pathway (39–42). If this is also true for human jejunum in vivo, as is generally assumed (17, 19, 20), absence of paracellular chloride absorption would reduce net electrolyte and water absorption in vivo, and the magnitude of this reduction would vary depending on the composition of intraluminal contents. As illustrated in the top right diagram of Figure 1, during perfusion of a balanced electrolyte solution, absence of paracellular chloride absorption would block passive NaCl absorption in response to chloride concentration gradients and modestly reduce the rate of electrolyte and water absorption. During perfusion of a glucose-saline solution (bottom right diagram of Figure 1), absence of paracellular chloride absorption through the paracellular pathway would require Na+ ions deposited into the subepithelial space to back-diffuse into the lumen (via the tight-junction pathway) in order to maintain electrical balance. Absence of passive paracellular chloride absorption in CF patients would therefore eliminate net NaCl absorption in response to Na+-glucose cotransport and it would markedly reduce water absorption. The persisting water absorption would be secondary to glucose translocation from lumen to plasma, which would not be reduced by absence of passive paracellular chloride absorption.
Absence of paracellular chloride absorption might be caused by reduction in size of the tight-junction aqueous channels through which chloride is transported. The normal L-xylose/urea diffusion coefficient ratio, however, suggests that the size of this pathway is not reduced in CF jejunum (29, 30). On the other hand, tight-junction permeability to ions might vary independent of pathway size. Experiments conducted in the 1960s (43) and 1970s (26, 44) indicated that control of ion permeation through the paracellular pathway is mediated by electrically charged groups within tight-junction aqueous channels. More recently, it has become apparent that several proteins, especially the family of claudin proteins, may determine ionic permeability characteristics of the tight junctions (45, 46). This may involve differences in electrostatic charge of the claudins and/or differences in the density of expression of unique claudins (47). Paracellular chloride absorption in the normal jejunum may depend on analogous, highly selective, tight-junction proteins.
Assuming that passive chloride absorption by the normal jejunum occurs through the paracellular shunt pathway, our finding that CF jejunum cannot absorb chloride suggests that CFTR regulates chloride permeability of jejunal tight junctions. This could involve a direct effect of CFTR on tight-junction proteins, or it might involve an indirect effect of CFTR mediated by cellular proteins, intracellular electrolyte concentrations or pH, intracellular volume, etc.
Although we favor a paracellular shunt explanation of our results, caution is advised for two reasons. First, there is no absolute proof that normal human jejunum in vivo absorbs chloride passively mainly through the paracellular pathway. Second, there is no precedence for invoking CFTR regulation of paracellular permeability.
Pathophysiological implications. Regardless of the mechanism responsible for absent chloride absorption by the jejunum of CF patients, the pathophysiological consequences are profound. In CF jejunum, chloride is an unabsorbable anion, and it therefore functions as an endogenous saline cathartic to retain fluid within the lumen. This would blunt the absorption of chloride-rich fluids that are normally present within the jejunum in the fasting state. In the fed state, glucose stimulates sodium absorption via Na+-glucose cotransport. This is the most powerful mechanism for promoting net jejunal NaCl and water absorption and is the physiological basis for oral rehydration of patients with cholera (48). Although CF patients absorbed glucose normally, their inability to passively absorb chloride blocked glucose-stimulated net sodium absorption and markedly reduced glucose-stimulated water absorption.
The classic intestinal ion transport defect in CF is the absence of active chloride secretion, which tends to dehydrate intestinal contents. The newly discovered defect in passive chloride absorption acts in physiological opposition to the classic defect. By retarding salt and water absorption, the absence of passive chloride absorption by CF jejunum would increase the volume of fluid delivered from the jejunum to the ileum. The ileum and colon actively absorb both sodium and chloride (17, 20, 23, 33, 49–52), so reduced passive chloride absorption in the ileum and colon, if this were to occur, would not reduce net fluid absorption to the extent that it does in the jejunum. Defective CFTR-mediated chloride secretion, therefore, might result in net fluid hyperabsorption by the ileum and colon. The higher than normal volumes of fluid delivered from CF jejunum to CF ileum, however, would reduce the likelihood that ileal and colonic contents would become dehydrated and inspissated. In this manner, the absence of passive chloride absorption in the jejunum would tend to protect CF patients against inspissated intestinal obstruction of the ileum and colon. Since our studies were done in adults, we do not know if the jejunum of infants and children with CF also have an abnormality in passive chloride absorption.
In contrast to CF in humans, most mouse models of CF produce a severe intestinal phenotype with a high incidence of death due to intestinal obstruction and perforation (53). In vitro techniques have not revealed significant ion transport differences between jejunal tissue from CF mouse models and CF patients (53), but in vivo studies, comparable to those described in this paper, have apparently not been conducted in CF mouse models. Perhaps CF mouse models lack the protective effect of jejunal chloride malabsorption that we found in CF patients, either because the mouse jejunum actively absorbs chloride or because CF mice do not have a defect in passive chloride absorption. If this were the case, it could be one of the reasons why CF mice have a much greater propensity than CF patients to develop severe intestinal disease.
These results in human jejunum in vivo suggest a possible beneficial effect from absent passive paracellular chloride absorption in patients with CF. The pathophysiology of CF lung disease has been attributed in part to excessive electrogenic absorption of sodium by airway epithelium (3, 54), followed by passive paracellular chloride absorption (55, 56). If passive paracellular chloride absorption can be manipulated by altering tight-junction proteins (47), blocking passive paracellular chloride absorption by CF airway cells might be a useful therapeutic objective to pursue.
This work was supported by U.S. Public Health grant 5-R01-DK37172 from the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases and by the Southwest Digestive Disease Foundation. Shmuel Muallem, of Southwestern Medical School, provided ongoing advice and support, and his many contributions to this research are gratefully acknowledged. Mark Feldman, Robert Alpern, Walter Peterson, and Michel Baum also provided helpful advice and suggestions. Mark Millard, Claude B. Prestidge, and Alberto Torres are the primary physicians responsible for the care of many of the patients, and their cooperation is greatly appreciated.
Conflict of interest: The authors have declared that no conflict of interest exists.
Nonstandard abbreviations used: cystic fibrosis (CF); CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR); polyethylene glycol (PEG); potential difference (PD).