Advertisement
VacA pores as portable portals for urea
Juanita L. Merchant
Internal Medicine and Physiology, University of Michigan, 1150 West Medical Center Drive, MSRB I, Room 3510, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-0650, USA.
Phone: (734) 647-2944; Fax: (734) 936-1400; E-mail: merchanj@umich.edu.
Find articles by Merchant, J. in: JCI | PubMed | Google Scholar
Published September 15, 2001 - More info
J Clin Invest. 2001;108(6):803–804. https://doi.org/10.1172/JCI14004.
© 2001 The American Society for Clinical Investigation
The epithelial linings of various organs have evolved to shield us from harmful aspects of our environment. In the stomach, the epithelial lining provides a reliable barrier against ingested microbes and toxins, in part by secreting copious amounts of gastric acid, whose major function is to sterilize the stomach contents (1). Whereas most microorganisms, peptides, and toxins cannot survive the low pH of the human stomach, the gastric epithelium has evolved to tolerate this environment, as have certain gastric bacteria, not all of which are benign.
Ulceration of the gastric mucosa was long attributed to excessive acid secretion triggered by stress, and the contribution of microorganisms was overlooked. More recently, it has been revealed that ulcers, like so many other diseases to which humans succumb, are primarily an infectious disorder (2). Nearly 20 years ago, when this hypothesis was confirmed (3), the idea that bacterial infection causes ulcers was considered heresy since no one believed that any organism could survive a pH less than 2. Warren and Marshall clearly demonstrated, however, that Helicobacter pylori thrives at low pH, and this bacterium is now known to be the major mechanism by which ulcers of the upper gastrointestinal tract are induced.
The question that remains unanswered is how H. pylori stimulates acid secretion and induces chronic gastritis. Initial studies identified several bacterial gene products that either are required for the organism to colonize and survive at low pH or might trigger inflammation in the infected stomach. VacA, a toxin expressed by most clinical isolates of H. pylori, meets both criteria. Coincubation of recombinant VacA protein with gastric cell lines induces vacuole formation in the cytoplasm (4), and VacA-expressing strains appear to colonize the stomach more efficiently (5). However, isogenic vacA mutants can colonize and trigger gastritis in both gnotobiotic piglets and Mongolian gerbils (6, 7). Thus, while VacA is clearly a type of virulence factor, it does not appear to be absolutely required for H. pylori virulence.
VacA is expressed as a 140-kDa precursor that is processed to a functional 94-kDa toxin. Following export and exposure to acid, this toxin assembles spontaneously into oligomers. Three domains are required for its activity: a 33–amino acid N-terminal signal sequence, which is cleaved from the mature protein but is required to direct the toxin to the periplasm; an N-terminal 37-kDa region, which contains the vacuolating activity; and a C-terminal 58-kDa region, which is required for binding of the protein to target cell membranes (8). Polymorphisms in VacA account for much of the variation among clinical isolates that can be distinguished antigenically (9). Numerous reports correlate the different isoforms of VacA with virulence. In contrast, another major H. pylori virulence factor, CagA, requires accessory factors expressed from the cag pathogenicity island to mediate its attack on cells. Several studies have now reported that CagA is translocated into the cytoplasm by a type IV secretory apparatus and is subsequently phosphorylated by host cell factors (10–13).
In this issue of the JCI, Tombola and colleagues report a specific function for VacA in the pathogenesis of stomach ulcers (14). They show here that H. pylori VacA binds preferentially to the apical plasma membrane, permeabilizing the host cell to urea. VacA therefore acts as a low pH–activated transmembrane pore. In addition to allowing the transport of neutral solutes, it may also allow the transport of electrolytes and therefore compromise the ability of the host cell to regulate its intracellular environment. While this process is toxic to the host epithelial cell, as evidenced by vacuole formation, VacA provides the bacterium with a competitive advantage by increasing the availability of urea. This metabolite can be converted to ammonia by the cytoplasmic enzyme urease in a reaction regulated by the proton-gated urea channel UreI. Because the accumulation of ammonia increases the buffering capacity within the periplasmic space (15), it appears that VacA improves the efficiency of a pH-sensitive homeostatic mechanism.
Unlike CagA, which requires an elaborate pore-forming structure to traverse the lipid bilayer, VacA can form pores in lipid bilayers autonomously, which classifies the toxin as a type V autotransporter pore (16). A common mechanism for pathogens that damage target cells without direct bacterial invasion is the ability to produce factors that punch holes through the host cell membrane, either by acting alone or by assembling a multi-subunit apparatus (16). These structures permit the flow of solutes from the environment through the outer and inner membranes of the bacteria, but they also disrupt the ability of the target cell to maintain integrity and homeostasis. Whether this is advantageous to the bacterium is unclear, since in many instances, the loss of cell integrity eventually cripples the cell. In response, the injured cell secretes chemokines that activate immune cells to attack the luminal pathogen.
Studies of Helicobacter infection in T or B cell–deficient mice show that Th1 cells, but not B lymphocytes, are required for the onset of gastritis (17, 18). Therefore, analogous to inflammatory bowel disease, which primarily affects the small and large bowels, smoldering inflammation in the stomach also appears to be responsible for the chronic tissue damage and neoplastic sequelae. Loss of differentiated cell types such as parietal and chief cells after months to years of cohabitation with the organism eventually compromises the stomach’s capacity to secrete acid and leads to a rise in gastric pH.
It is not obvious how loss of parietal cells and the eventual rise in gastric pH might benefit the bacteria. Although this has not been tested directly, it seems unlikely that H. pylori can colonize the gastric epithelium efficiently in the absence of acid (15, 19). Reduced colonization may be due to insufficient gastric acid to counterbalance the ammonia produced by the organism. Moreover, with a rise in pH, the stomach is at risk of colonization by less fastidious bacterial species, which may then out-compete H. pylori (20, 21). Thus, in the end, H. pylori may merely be the trigger for a cascade of events that is sustained by the immune system and by repopulation of the stomach by organisms other than H. pylori.
While most H. pylori strains express vacA, there is poor correlation of vacA status with clinical disease and outcome in non-US populations (22, 23). Asian and other non-Western populations make up a large proportion of the world’s population infected with H. pylori (∼50%). Moreover, in vitro studies demonstrate that VacA protein is not required to induce an inflammatory response and colonize animal models (6, 24), implying that non-VacA H. pylori strains must be able to transport urea effectively to survive in the acidic stomach. Since vacA mutants obviously still colonize the normal acid-secreting stomach, it may be that other pore-forming molecules perform an analogous function in these strains (25). The identification of other such proteins may be needed for vaccine development, since it is probable that targeting VacA alone will not generate a universal vaccine (26). Rather, a cocktail of multiple H. pylori–specific factors will likely be required.
Copyright © 2025 American Society for Clinical Investigation
ISSN: 0021-9738 (print), 1558-8238 (online)