Published in Volume
121, Issue 1
(January 4, 2011)J Clin Invest.
Copyright © 2011, American Society for Clinical Investigation
Spontaneous abrogation of the G2 DNA damage checkpoint has clinical benefits but promotes leukemogenesis in Fanconi anemia patients
1INSERM U944 and
2Hematology Laboratory Assistance Publique – Hôpitaux de Paris (APHP), Saint-Louis Hospital, Paris, France.
3Institute of Hematology (IUH), University Paris Diderot, Paris, France.
4Laboratory of Cellular Biology, Saint-Louis Hospital, Paris, France.
5Oncogenetic Laboratory, Curie Institute, Paris, France.
6Vrije University, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
7Hematology Department, Necker Hospital, Paris, France.
8Institut d’Hématologie et d’Oncologie-Pédiatrique, Hospices civils de Lyon, Lyon, France.
9Department of Pediatric Hematology, Saint-Louis and Robert Debré Hospitals, Paris, France.
11Department of Bone Marrow Transplant, Saint-Louis Hospital, Paris, France.
Address correspondence to: Jean Soulier, Genome and Cancer, INSERM U944 and CNRS UMR7212, Institute of Hematology, Saint-Louis Hospital, 1 Av Claude, Vellefaux 75010, Paris, France. Phone: 33.1.4249.9891; Fax: 33.1.4249.4027; E-mail:
Authorship note: Raphael Ceccaldi, Nadia Vasquez, Delphine Chamousset, Thierry Leblanc, Eliane Gluckman, Gérard Socié, and Jean Soulier are members of the French National Reference Center for Constitutional Bone Marrow Failure.
First published December 22, 2010
Submitted: May 27,
2010; Accepted: November 3,
DNA damage checkpoints in the cell cycle may be important barriers against cancer progression in human cells. Fanconi anemia (FA) is an inherited DNA instability disorder that is associated with bone marrow failure and a strong predisposition to cancer. Although FA cells experience constitutive chromosomal breaks, cell cycle arrest at the G2 DNA damage checkpoint, and an excess of cell death, some patients do become clinically stable, and the mechanisms underlying this, other than spontaneous reversion of the disease-causing mutation, are not well understood. Here we have defined a clonal phenotype, termed attenuation, in which FA patients acquire an abrogation of the G2 checkpoint arrest. Attenuated cells expressed lower levels of CHK1 (also known as CHEK1) and p53. The attenuation could be recapitulated by modulating the ATR/CHK1 pathway, and CHK1 inhibition protected FA cells from cell death. FA patients who expressed the attenuated phenotype had mild bone marrow deficiency and reached adulthood, but several of them eventually developed myelodysplasia or leukemia. Better understanding of attenuation might help predict a patient’s clinical course and guide choice of treatment. Our results also highlight the importance of evaluating the cellular DNA damage checkpoint and repair pathways in cancer therapies in general.
Checkpoint pathways are complex biological pathways that regulate responses to DNA damage and other cellular events (1–3). The typical DNA damage checkpoint response triggers cell cycle arrest, allowing time for DNA repair, and impairments in checkpoints favor genomic instability and cancer (4). In humans, DNA damage checkpoint pathways include the posttranslational activation of the transduction proteins CHK1 checkpoint homolog (Schizosaccharomyces pombe) (CHK1, also known as CHEK1) and CHK2 checkpoint homolog (S. pombe) (CHK2) by PI3-like kinase ataxia telangiectasia and Rad3 related (ATR) and ataxia telangiectasia mutated (ATM) (4, 5). If cells can not repair damage during cell cycle arrest, cell death is induced. Recently, DNA damage response pathways have also been implicated in cellular responses to oncogenic activation, and checkpoint pathways are believed to constitute a first-line anticancer barrier (6–8). Therefore, an important step of cancer progression is the inactivation of checkpoint pathways. Here we studied a series of patients with Fanconi anemia (FA), a genetic disease that is characterized by genomic instability, checkpoint arrest, and cancer predisposition and identified what we believe to be a new cellular phenotype that is associated with clonal evolution and leukemogenesis.
FA is an inherited condition that is caused by mutations in 1 out of the 13 FA-associated genes (9, 10). Products of these genes interact in the FANC/BRCA pathway, in which a pivotal event is the monoubiquitination of FA, complementation group D2 (FANCD2) (11). Affected patients can develop various congenital abnormalities, including short stature (12, 13). They usually experience bone marrow failure during childhood, and they have a considerable predisposition to cancer, especially myelodysplasia (MDS), acute myeloid leukemia (AML), and head and neck cancers (12–16). FA cells are hypersensitive to DNA interstrand crosslinking (ICL) agents and harbor high levels of spontaneous and induced chromosome breaks (9, 10, 12, 13). On exposure to ICL agents, such as mitomycin C (MMC), FA cells undergo massive G2 arrest, which is considered a normal checkpoint response to unresolved DNA damage during S phase (17–19). Consequently, FA cells experience slower progression through the cell cycle, inhibition of growth, increased p53 expression, and cell death (20–22). FA cells can undergo somatic mosaicism by spontaneous reverse mutation or mitotic recombination (23–25). This phenomenon of reversion allows genetically corrected cells to be selected to repopulate the bone marrow. This spontaneous “endogenous gene therapy” has been associated with higher blood cell counts and clinical improvement (25, 26) and occasionally with cancer (27).
In this study, we describe a type of clonal evolution in FA — attenuation of the G2 checkpoint — which does not correct genomic instability but overrides it by promoting cell survival. The biological pathways that are involved in cell cycle checkpoints, including the ATR-CHK1 axis, were investigated in attenuated FA cells. Patients with attenuated cells were clinically stable, but some eventually developed leukemia. These data, based on a human genetic condition, highlight the complex relationships among genomic instability, clonal evolution, cell survival, and cancer. The cellular mechanisms and concepts in FA patients that we describe have implications for general cancer biology and responses to chemotherapy.
A new phenotype in FA patients — attenuation of the G2 checkpoint in response to DNA damage.
FA cells are characteristically hypersensitive to DNA crosslinking agents. During diagnosis or follow-up evaluation of FA patients, we noted patients in whom the FA tests on peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) were dissociated. In these patients, phytohemagglutinin-stimulated (PHA-stimulated) fresh PBLs did not arrest in G2 phase after MMC exposure, although they harbored chromosomal breaks and lacked FANCD2 monoubiquitination (Figure 1 and Supplemental Figure 1; supplemental material available online with this article; doi:
10.1172/JCI43836DS1). The abrogation of the G2 checkpoint was previously reported in rare (non-FA) cancer cell lines, and it was defined as attenuation (28). Based on our observation, we hypothesized that the G2 checkpoint can be attenuated in FA cells, prompting us to evaluate this phenomenon in a large cohort of FA patients. We defined the attenuated phenotype as the combination of (a) a high level of chromosomal breaks after MMC exposure in the Fanconi range (“positive chromosome breakage test”); (b) a lack of FANCD2 monoubiquitination, characteristic of FA cells with an upstream defect in the FA/BRCA pathway (“positive FANCD2 test”); and (c) a paradoxical absence or significant decrease in MMC-induced FA cell G2 arrest (“negative cell cycle test”). These criteria allowed us to differentiate the attenuated phenotype from that of “classical” FA, in which all 3 tests are positive, and from that of reversion, in which the 3 tests are completely or partially normalized (somatic mosaicism).
Attenuation of G2 arrest — a new phenotype in FA.
(A) Cell cycle analysis of PHA-stimulated PBLs from a classical FA patient (FA), an attenuated FA patient (ATT), a revertant (REV; somatic mosaic), and a healthy control (Ctrl). The arrow indicates the typical MMC-induced G2 arrest of classical FA cells, and the asterisk designates the G2 checkpoint abrogation in the attenuated cells; as expected, revertant cells demonstrated no G2 arrest. (B) Cell cycle analysis of primary fibroblasts (fibro) from the same patients, showing G2 arrest (arrow) and confirming the constitutive FA phenotype and dissociation with PBLs in attenuated and revertant patients. Horizontal bars in A and B indicate the G1 and G2 cell cycle phases (M1 and M2, respectively). (C) Immunoblot analysis showed that attenuated FA PBLs lacked the large monoubiquitinated 162-kDa isoform of FANCD2 (asterisk), like classical FA cells and unlike revertant cells; primary fibroblasts retained the FA phenotype. (D) Attenuated cells still have a high number of MMC-induced chromosomal breaks, like classical FA cells and unlike revertant cells (original magnification, ×630). Arrows indicate the chromosome breaks. Breaks scoring are shown in Supplemental Figure 1. (E) Classification of the FA patients as having classical, revertant, and attenuated PBL phenotypes and ordering by class age: fewer than 5 years (n = 9; 9.5%), 5–9 years (n = 31; 32.6%), 10–14 years (n = 15; 15.8%), 15–19 years (n = 11; 11.6%), 20–24 years (n = 10; 10.5%), 25–29 years (n = 9; 9.5%), and more than 30 years (n = 10; 10.5%). For the clarity of the figure, 2 patients whose fibroblasts were later found to be intermediate for G2 arrest are not shown (see text).
Attenuation is found in older FA patients and is associated with milder bone marrow failure or MDS/leukemia. We evaluated a cohort of 97 FA patients (group FA-A, n = 80; FA-G, n = 9; FA-D2, n = 7; other, n = 1) for the presence of attenuation. This cohort included FA patients at Saint-Louis Hospital who underwent a complete analysis of fresh PBLs, particularly in the oldest patients, and excluded bone marrow transplantation patients. The 97 patients were classified as classical FA (i.e., patients with a standard FA phenotype), revertant, or attenuated. Sixty-eight out of ninety-seven patients had classical FA (70.1%), 12 patients had a revertant phenotype (12.4%), and 17 patients had the attenuated phenotype (17.5%). Patients with the attenuated phenotype were clearly not revertants, because they had a positive chromosome breakage test and lacked FANCD2 monoubiquitination in PHA-stimulated PBLs. In addition, reversion events were not observed after resequencing the FANC mutations in the PBLs of the attenuated patients (n = 10), whereas 3 revertant cases, tested as controls, harbored a point reversion in DNA from their PBLs (data not shown).
We analyzed the distribution of the FA phenotypes by patient age (Figure 1E). Notably, whereas reversion and attenuation were rare compared with classical FA in young patients, most patients with an attenuated or revertant phenotype were over 20 years of age. The median blood cell count in attenuated patients approximated normal levels (hemoglobin, 12.6 g/l; white blood cells, 3.9 × 109/l, neutrophil cells, 1.8 × 109/l, platelets 106 × 109/l), suggesting that attenuation, like reversion (26), was associated with a better clinical outcome with respect to bone marrow failure, allowing patients to reach adulthood (7 out of the 17 patients with the attenuated phenotype did not experience bone marrow failure; Supplemental Table 1). Notably, 5 FA patients (aged 16, 20, 26, 36, and 50 years) with the attenuated phenotype in PHA-stimulated PBLs developed MDS or AML (Supplemental Table 1).
Collectively, these data demonstrate that attenuation is frequent in older FA patients and is associated with better clinical outcomes but also that it can be found in patients with MDS or leukemia.
The attenuated phenotype is acquired. Next, we determined whether the attenuated phenotype was acquired or constitutive. The FANC data from the 17 attenuated phenotype patients could not exclude in all cases the possibility of hypomorphic mutations (Supplemental Table 1 and ref. 29). Therefore, we performed FA tests on primary fibroblasts, as constitutive cells, which we could perform for 16 out of 17 patients. Two patients experienced intermediate G2 arrest and mild MMC sensitivity in their fibroblasts, and they were excluded from further analysis. In the remaining 14 patients, primary fibroblasts showed massive MMC-induced G2 arrest, typical of FA (Figure 1B and Supplemental Table 1). The patent difference between the PBL and fibroblast data demonstrated that attenuation, like reversion, was an acquired, not constitutive, phenotype. In addition, conversion from the classical to attenuated FA phenotype occurred in 2 patients at distant analyses (at 6- and 3-year intervals, respectively; Supplemental Figure 2).
Clonality of attenuated cells. To determine whether attenuation in PBLs was related to clonal evolution, we searched for somatic chromosomal abnormalities. Genomic DNA from PBLs of attenuated patients was subjected to high-resolution chromosomal profiling (array-CGH/SNP). In 8 out of 13 cases, gross chromosomal copy number alterations were observed (Figure 2A and Supplemental Table 1). Notably, such alterations included several chromosomal abnormalities that are common in FA clonal evolution, such as gain of chromosome arm 1q or 3q and deletion of 11q.
Clonality of attenuated FA cells. (A) Array-CGH showed clonal chromosomal abnormalities in PHA-stimulated PBLs from an attenuated patient. MGG stains confirmed the activated lymphoblast morphology (original magnification, ×400). Arrows indicate copy number abnormalities. (B) X-linked–based analysis of clonality; female FA patients who were heterozygous for 1 or more of the 3 SNPs in the X chromosome were identified by direct sequencing of genomic DNA. Then, allelic X-linked inactivation was evaluated in a semiquantitative manner by sequencing PBL cDNA from these patients. The left panel shows balanced expression of the heterozygous MMP1 SNP in a healthy control and a classical FA patient, whereas skewed expression was detected in the attenuated and revertant patients (asterisks). The right panel summarizes the X-linked clonality data in heterozygous PBLs from healthy female controls (n = 11), attenuated patients (n = 5), revertants (n = 1), and classical FA subjects (n = 6). The percentage of skewing expression is quantified for each case, and median values are indicated by horizontal bars. The threshold for skewed unbalanced expression was arbitrarily fixed (dashed horizontal line). Each symbol represents a patient.
In a separate approach, we measured clonality by X-linked inactivation analysis (Figure 2B). All 5 patients with the attenuated phenotype who could be analyzed, including 3 without detectable chromosomal abnormalities, showed skewed allelic expression that was consistent with clonal selection. In contrast, nearly all healthy controls had a balanced pattern. As expected, the revertant patient showed skewed allelic expression. Balanced allelic expression was observed in 3 out of 6 classical FA patients, consistent with polyclonal cells, and interestingly, a skewed expression was noted in the 3 others, suggesting that mechanisms other than attenuation also lead to clonal restriction in FA.
Collectively, these data are consistent with a model of natural selection of the attenuated cells in FA patients.
Downregulation of checkpoint proteins in attenuated FA cells. We hypothesized that an acquired defect in the checkpoint pathways caused the attenuated phenotype. Expression of the prototypical DNA damage response proteins CHK1, CHK2, and p53 was measured in fresh blood samples from 9 attenuated phenotype patients, 14 classical FA subjects, and 4 healthy samples (Figure 3). p53 expression was high in classical FA cells compared with that in healthy controls (Figure 3A), suggesting that p53 is induced in fresh FA cells in response to endogenous and induced DNA damage, consistent with previous reports of human FA EBV cell lines and murine fibroblasts (20–22). Notably, we observed low expression of CHK1 and p53 in the PHA-stimulated PBLs of 6 out of 9 attenuated phenotype patients compared with that in classical FA subjects but not in the fibroblasts (Figure 3A and data not shown). Moreover, low levels of CHK1 but not CHK2 transcripts were detected by real-time quantitative PCR (RQ-PCR) in most attenuated patients compared with patients with classical FA (Figure 3B). By analyzing sequence and copy number of CHK1 and TP53 in low-expression level patients, no genomic mutation or focused deletion was detected, suggesting other mechanisms of deregulation. We therefore investigated epigenetic changes. Whereas we found no DNA methylation changes in attenuated cells (Supplemental Figure 3A), in silico analysis of CHK1 3′ UTR predicted numerous target sites for 2 microRNAs, namely miR15-a and miR16-1, which were previously reported to target CHK1 expression (30); interestingly, we found a higher expression of miR15-a, but not miR16-1, in attenuated cells compared with that in classical FA cells, suggesting a mechanism of CHK1 expression downregulation (Supplemental Figure 3B). In addition, unlike CHK2, which is a stable protein, CHK1 is a rather unstable protein due to proteasome degradation (31). We evaluated CHK1 turnover and found an acceleration in the attenuated cells, demonstrating that posttranslational mechanisms could also contribute to the low levels of CHK1, which were observed during attenuation (Figure 3C).
Low expression of CHK1 and p53, but not CHK2, in attenuated FA patients. (A) Immunoblot analysis of PHA-stimulated PBL extracts from an attenuated FA patient, 2 classical FA subjects, and a healthy donor, with increasing concentrations of MMC. (B) CHK1 and CHK2 levels were quantified by RQ-PCR in PHA-stimulated PBLs of classical FA patients (n = 11), attenuated FA patients (n = 8), and healthy donors (n = 3). RQ-PCR copy number values are expressed using the ΔCT method relative to a housekeeping gene (reverse log2 scale). Mean values are indicated by horizontal bars. Statistical analyses were performed using the non-parametric Wilcoxon test (*P < 0.05). Each symbol represents a patient. (C) As shown in the left panel, proteasome inhibition partially restored CHK1 levels in the attenuated cells. Attenuated and control PHA-stimulated PBLs were incubated with the proteasome inhibitor MG132 or control DMSO for 4 hours. Then the level of CHK1 protein was analyzed by immunoblotting. As shown in the right panel, translational inhibition by CHX treatment revealed an increase of CHK1 decay in the attenuated PHA-stimulated PBLs compared with that in control PHA-stimulated PBLs. The CHK2 level was analyzed in parallel as a more stable protein.
Based on these data, the transcriptional and/or posttranslational downregulation of CHK1 expression constituted a putative mechanism for attenuation of the G2 checkpoint in FA cells.
Suppression of the ATR/CHK1 checkpoint pathway reproduced the attenuated phenotype and protects FA cells from DNA damage-induced cell death in short-term culture. We determined whether attenuation could be recapitulated by checkpoint inhibition. We used an siRNA FANCD2-silenced HeLa cell line as an FA-like cell line for its convenience with cotransfection. G2 arrest was abrogated in CHK1- and ATR-depleted cells; in contrast, ATM, CHK2, and BRCA1 depletion did not affect G2 arrest (Figure 4A). We then evaluated the effect of checkpoint inhibitors on FA lymphoblastoid (EBV-immortalized) cells. An inhibitor of CHK1, but not CHK2, relieved the G2 arrest (Figure 4B). Similarly, fresh FA PBLs were converted to attenuated cells by the CHK1 inhibitor (Supplemental Figure 4).
Inhibition of CHK1 and ATR, but not CHK2, ATM, or BRCA1, mimics the attenuated phenotype in FA cells. (A) Cell cycle analysis of MMC-induced G2 arrest in HeLa cells transfected with combinations of siRNAs (si) against luciferase (control), FANCD2, and the checkpoint genes CHK1, CHK2, ATR, ATM, and BRCA1, as indicated. FANCD2-silenced HeLa cells displayed a strong MMC-induced G2 arrest and were used as FA-like cells for convenience in cotransfection experiments. The immunoblot shows the knockdown of different proteins for each siRNA. Arrows and asterisks indicate typical FA G2 arrest and its abrogation, respectively. All data were obtained in at least 3 independent experiments for each targeted gene with consistent results. (B) Abrogation of MMC-induced G2 arrest by the CHK1 inhibitor SB-218078 (CHK1i) but not by the CHK2 inhibitor C3742 (CHK2i) in FA and non-FA EBV cells. DMSO was used as control, and all data were obtained in 3 independent experiments with consistent results. The arrows indicate the MMC-induced G2 arrest, and the asterisk designates the G2 checkpoint abrogation. Horizontal bars in A and B indicate the G1 and G2 cell cycle phases (M1 and M2, respectively).
We next examined whether CHK1 inhibition protected FA cells from MMC-induced cell death in short-term cultures. FA primary fibroblasts were grown with or without CHK1 inhibitor in increasing concentrations of MMC. Cell death was reflected by the nascent fraction of cellular fragments (sub-G1) by flow cytometry. Strikingly, FA cells that were incubated with the CHK1 inhibitor were protected from MMC-induced death (Figure 5 and Supplemental Figure 5).
CHK1 inhibitor protects FA cells from DNA damage-induced cell death in short-term cultures. (A) Representative flow cytometry–based analysis of cell death of FA primary fibroblasts, with or without CHK1i. The fraction of cellular fragments (sub-G1, bars) was measured in each condition. Consistent data were obtained in at least 2 experiments for each of 4 unrelated FA patients. (B) Graphic representation of the percentage of cellular fragments measured in A. Annexin V staining is shown in Supplemental Figure 5. (C) MGG staining of FA primary fibroblasts with or without CHK1i treatment with 25 ng/ml MMC (original magnification, ×160).
These data demonstrate that inhibition of CHK1 or ATR, but not CHK2, ATM, or BRCA1, mimics the attenuated phenotype in FA cells. The absence of CHK1 abrogates the G2 checkpoint and protects FA cells from death, consistent with our hypothesis that clonal attenuation in FA improves survival.
Attenuated phenotype in FA patients with MDS with excess blasts or acute leukemia. Five out of the ninety-seven FA patients had MDS with an excess of blasts or overt myeloid leukemia. In all of these patients, aged 16, 20, 26, 36 and 50 years, the PHA-stimulated PBLs had the attenuated phenotype (i.e., chromosome breaks and no FANCD2 monoubiquitination but no G2 arrest). This finding raises the possibility that the attenuated phenotype is involved in malignant transformation. We could purify blast cells from fresh bone marrow aspirate in 4 out of the 5 patients and measured CHK1 and CHK2 expression. The clonal origin and purity of the CD34-sorted cells were confirmed by array-CGH (data not shown). Importantly, the tumoral cells expressed minute levels of CHK1 but not of CHK2 (Figure 6), reminiscent of what was observed in attenuated PBLs, suggesting that leukemic cells would be unable to arrest through the ATR-CHK1 axis. In line with published data (32), very low levels of CHK1 were also found in a reference series of primary AML cells from non-FA patients (Figure 6), consistent with a model of suppression of the DNA damage response in AML as a late transformation event (Figure 7). Importantly, chemotherapy treatment (33) effected complete remission in these FA patients with MDS/AML, demonstrating that the leukemic cells were sensitive to chemotherapy.
Low expression of CHK1, but not CHK2, in the leukemic cells from MDS/AML FA patients (n = 4).
Leukemic cells were purified by CD34+ selection; the clonality and high purity of the blast cell fraction was demonstrated in all of the 4 MDS/AML FA patients by array-CGH profiling, which detected chromosomal alterations (data not shown). Data from classical FA patient PHA-stimulated PBLs are indicated as reference (several samples were reanalyzed with consistent results). Leukemic cells from a series of non-FA patients (n = 15) with AML were analyzed as malignant reference. RQ-PCR copy number values are expressed using the ΔCT method relative to a housekeeping gene (reverse log2 scale). Mean values are indicated by horizontal bars. Statistical analyses were performed using the non-parametric test Wilcoxon test (**P < 0.001). As expected from published data in MDS and AML in non-FA patients (32), very low levels of CHK1 transcripts were also found in the non-FA AML cells. Each symbol represents a patient.
Genomic instability, DNA damage response, and stepwise oncogenesis — a model of stepwise progression to MDS/AML in patients with or without constitutive genetic instability. In FA patients, the first step is constitutive and leads to excess cell death related to the G2 checkpoint response; the attenuation phenomenon described here rescues cell survival and allows for the accumulation of additional oncogenic events that are favored by the genetic instability. In patients that are not genetically predisposed (non-FA patients), activation of oncogenes is associated with acquired genetic instability and induction of anticancer DNA damage response (6–8); further inactivation of this response, often by TP53 inactivation, allows cancer progression to late stages (6–8, 32, 44, 47). Notably, no TP53 mutation or deletion was observed in the 5 MDS/AML leukemia cases that developed in attenuated FA patients in our series (data not shown).
Based on our analysis of patients who were evaluated in a specialist center, we identified a type of spontaneous evolution in FA — attenuation, an acquired abrogation of the G2 checkpoint in FA cells (Figure 1). FA patients with the attenuated phenotype were older than classical FA subjects and had near-normal blood cell counts, suggesting that this phenotype is beneficial for hematopoiesis. Therefore, our working hypothesis has been that checkpoint attenuation allows FA cells to survive despite spontaneous DNA damage, whereas in classical (not attenuated) FA cells, the DNA damage response pathway is deleterious by triggering unresolved checkpoint arrest. The distribution of the various phenotypes (classical, attenuated, and revertant) throughout different age groups suggests that a model exists in which hematopoiesis evolves clonally in most FA patients during adolescence or early adulthood as a response to stem cell exhaustion and selective pressure. Such evolution can arise spontaneously through attenuation or reversion, or it can be driven by allogeneic bone marrow transplantation. Attenuation could explain the pattern in families in which FA siblings have patent phenotypic differences despite similar genotypes, reminiscent of what has been observed for reversion. Notably, neither attenuation (this work), nor reversion (27) appears to protect against transformation into MDS and leukemia, and we believe that all FA patients have to be monitored for cancer detection for life, including, if possible, by a yearly bone marrow aspirate.
We investigated the biological mechanisms of attenuation by analyzing the prototypical checkpoint pathways in FA cells. CHK1 levels, but not CHK2 levels, were frequently very low in attenuated blood cells. CHK1 downregulation was related to transcriptional and/or posttranslational mechanisms, and interestingly, miR15-a, previously reported to silent CHK1 (30), could contribute to the low CHK1 levels. Downregulation of the ATR-CHK1 axis, but not ATM-CHK2 or BRCA1, by siRNA or chemical inhibitors abrogated the G2 arrest, mimicking the attenuated phenotype and confirming that CHK1 function is pivotal for G2 accumulation in FA cells (34–36). Moreover, CHK1 inhibition protected FA cells from DNA damage-induced immediate cell death, consistent with our model, in which G2 checkpoint attenuation allows FA cells to grow despite spontaneous DNA damage, in contrast to deleterious checkpoint responses in classical FA cells. In addition, CHK1 downregulation is likely to contribute to the genetic instability through deregulation of the normal cell cycle transitions, especially G1/S and G2/M (refs. 37 and 38 and Supplemental Figure 6). In genomic analyses of attenuated PBLs, we did not detect any mutation or focused deletion in CHK1 or TP53 but observed that these cells experienced frequent gross somatic chromosomal alterations, such as duplication of chromosome 1q (Supplemental Table 1). Notably, this chromosomal abnormality is commonly associated with clonal evolution in FA (39, 40), and it might be involved in the attenuation mechanism. It is noteworthy that the molecular target and related downstream pathways of gross chromosomal abnormalities in neoplasias remain largely to be identified, see for instance trisomy 8 or monosomy 7 in clonal evolution of aplastic anemia or MDS/AML in non-FA patients (41–44). Finally, it is likely that other changes in pathways that regulate cellular stress, apoptosis, and senescence can also contribute to cell survival and transformation throughout the natural history of FA patients, as occurs in mice (45).
Genomic instability is a common feature of cancer, wherein it promotes the accumulation of genomic alterations, leading to the deregulation of oncogenes and tumor suppressor genes (46). In very rare genetic conditions, such as FA, the instability is constitutive, and patients with this condition have a strong predisposition to cancer (12–16). Recently, the DNA damage response has emerged as a major anticancer barrier, and DNA damage response inactivation is an important step for cancer progression (6–8). In our FA cohort, 5 patients with attenuated PBLs experienced MDS or AML. Strikingly, the leukemic cells expressed CHK2 but very low levels of CHK1, suggesting that these cells would fail to elicit CHK1-dependent checkpoint arrest. Therefore, the attenuation phenomenon might contribute to leukemogenesis by promoting survival in an FA background of constitutive genomic instability (Figure 7). In patients who do not have a genetic predisposition (non-FA patients), the common stepwise order of oncogenic events likely differs slightly (Figure 7). The genomic instability and induction of the DNA damage checkpoint are not constitutive but are likely to be induced as a consequence of the initial oncogenic events (6–8), as in primary human MDS and AML (32, 44). As a result, the inactivation of DNA damage response pathways, often by TP53 inactivation, would allow cells to survive despite the persistent genomic instability, accelerating the progression to late stages (6–8, 32, 44, 47).
These findings and concepts have important implications, not only for gaining a better understanding of the clinical course of FA, but also for developing cancer treatments for FA and non-FA patients. Based on our data, the acquired attenuation of checkpoints gives a survival advantage to FA cells in a background of endogenous DNA damage. In contrast, one can predict that attenuated cancer cells will be highly sensitive to chemotherapy, unlike revertant cancer cells (27). In an environment of high and sustained DNA damage, such as that during chemotherapy, attenuated cells will die due to checkpoint deficiencies and mitotic dysfunction. Accordingly, the 5 FA patients with MDS/AML and the attenuated phenotype who we evaluated responded very well to usual FA chemotherapy (33), and only 1 experienced a relapse 7–42 months after treatment. Interestingly, these results and concepts in patients are consistent with a recent preclinical model in mice, in which concomitant abnormal levels of Atm, Chk2, and p53 are more sensitive to chemotherapy (48).
In conclusion, we believe that a careful evaluation of hematopoietic attenuation and reversion in FA patients can help understand and predict the clinical course of the disease. Further, in non-FA patients, the evaluation of genomic instability and checkpoint and repair pathways in cancer cells should also help clinicians tailor the chemotherapy and specifically target the relevant checkpoint/repair pathways (16, 49–53).
Patients and biological material collection and cell lines. This study was based on a cohort of FA patients, followed for 6 years at Saint-Louis Hospital, the French national reference center for FA. Written informed consent was obtained from the patients and/or their relatives. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board at Hôpital Saint-Louis. Patients were aged 1 to 56 years (median age, 12 years). All patients had an FA diagnosis based on classical FA tests, including the chromosomal breakage test (12, 26). The FA-associated gene mutation data have been entered into the international IFAR registry (www.rockefeller.edu/fanconi/mutate); mutations data in the patients with the attenuated phenotype are described in Supplemental Table 1. The 97 patients were distributed as follows: FA-A, n = 80; FA-G, n = 9; FA-D2, n = 7; other, n = 1, which is representative of all French FA patients. Patients were referred to using a unique identification number (EGF), following our nomenclature. Blood cells and primary fibroblasts were collected. CD34-positive cells from bone marrow of MDS/AML FA patients were purified using the CD34 MicroBead Kit (Miltenyi).
Several cell lines were EBV-derived from FA patients at our center and used for this study. The HeLa cell line that was used for functional studies was obtained from ATCC.
Cell culture and FA tests. Chromosomal breakage tests and FANCD2 monoubiquitination analysis by immunoblot were performed on PBLs and fibroblasts using conventional methods (12, 26, 54).
For cell cycle analysis, MMC was used at 0, 30, and 75 ng/ml for PHA-stimulated PBLs and at 0, 10, and 25 ng/ml for primary fibroblasts. In all experiments, growing cells (fresh PHA-stimulated PBLs or cultured primary fibroblasts) were treated with MMC, fixed in chilled 70% ethanol, washed with PBS after overnight storage at –20°C, and resuspended in propidium iodide in PBS with 0.1% Triton X-100 and 100 μg/ml DNase-free RNase A. The stained cells were sorted on a Becton Dickinson FACSCalibur and analyzed using CellQuest (Becton Dickinson). Approximately 10,000 cells per sample were analyzed. EBV and HeLa cells were treated with 0 and 75 ng/ml or 100 ng/ml MMC, respectively.
FA cell death after a 96-hour incubation with MMC, with or without CHK1 inhibitor, was calculated by measuring the percentage of cellular fragments (sub-G1), derived from a flow-based MMC-hypersensitivity test in primary fibroblasts (55). In parallel experiments, FA primary fibroblasts were grown in a Lab-tekII Chamber Slide (Nalge Nunc International) in increasing dilutions of MMC, with or without CHK1 inhibitor, and analyzed by in situ staining of adherent cells with May Grundwald Giemsa (MGG). Apoptosis was further analyzed by Annexin V staining.
Chemical inhibitors. Chemical inhibitors against CHK1 (CHK1i; SB-218078 [Calbiochem]) and CHK2 (CHK2i; C3742 [Sigma-Aldrich]), were dissolved in DMSO and used at a final concentration of 1 μM and 100 nM, respectively. The diluted solution of DMSO was used as control.
The translational inhibitor, cycloheximide (CHX; Calbiochem) and the proteasome inhibitor MG132 (Calbiochem) were dissolved in DMSO and used at a final concentration of 25 μg/ml and 20 μM, respectively. The diluted solution of DMSO was used as control.
Transfection. Targeted genes were knocked down by transient expression of siRNA against FANCD2 (5′-GGAGAUUGAUGGUCUACUAdTdT-3′), LUC (5′-CGUACGCGGAAUACUUCGAdTdT-3′), CHK1 (5′-GGACUUCUCUCCAGUAAACdTdT-3′), CHK2 (5′-GAACCUGAGGAGCCUACCCdTdT-3′), ATR (5′-AACCUCCGUGAUGUUGCUUGAdTdT-3′), ATM (5′-AAGCGCCUGAUUCGAGAUCCUdTdT-3′), and BRCA1 (5′-CUAGAAAUCUGUUGCUAUGdTdT-3′). All siRNA duplexes were purchased from Eurogentec, except CHK1, which was purchased from Dharmacon. siRNA or the combination of 2 different siRNAs were used at a final concentration of 100 nM. siRNA duplexes were transfected using the Lipofectamine Reagent (Invitrogen) according to the manufacturer’s recommendations. Luciferase-specific siRNA served as the negative control. In all experiments, a fraction of transfected cells was analyzed by immunoblot to assess knockdown efficiency. For cell cycle experiments using transfected cells, HeLa cells were plated 24 hours before transfection, MMC was added 72 hours after transfection, and cells were harvested at 96 hours and immediately fixed.
Evaluation of clonality. Array-CGH (105K, Agilent Technologies) or SNP-array (500K, Affymetrix) were used for genomic PBL DNA according to the manufacturer’s protocols. For SNP analysis, paired fibroblast DNA was used as a reference. Data were analyzed using DNA Analytics (Agilent Technologies) or Genomic Suite (Partek).
For X-linked inactivation analysis (56), 3 SNPs in X chromosome genes, subjected to X-linked inactivation, were studied: dbSNP 1126762 (MPP1), dbSNP 9018 (FHL1), and dbSNP 1135363 (BTK). Primer sequences are shown in Supplemental Figure 7A. Briefly, SNPs were sequenced from genomic DNA of female FA patients to determine heterozygosity. The relative expression of each allele was determined by direct sequencing of PBL cDNA. Balanced or skewed ratios were determined by direct evaluation of the chromatograms. Healthy females were evaluated as control.
Immunoblotting. Cell lysates were prepared in 50 mM Tris-HCl, 150 mM NaCl, 0.1% SDS, and 1% NP-40 buffer. Antibodies were purchased against CHK1, CHK2, p53, ATM, CDC25A, actin (all from Santa Cruz Biotechnology Inc.), FANCD2 (Novus Biologicals), ATR (Cell Signaling), BRCA1 (Calbiochem), and vinculin (Abcam). Signals were detected using an ECL kit (Pierce) and visualized with a Fuji LAS-3000 luminescent image analyzer system.
CHK1 and CHK2 gene expression, miRNA expression. RNA samples, extracted from PHA-stimulated PBLs were reverse transcribed, and the cDNA was analyzed for CHK1 and CHK2 expression by RQ-PCR using TaqMan methods (Applied Biosystems). Expression values were normalized to expression of the housekeeping gene GUS, using the ΔCT method, and are shown on a log2 scale.
After extraction of the dry pellet with the miRNeasy Kit, RT and RQ-PCR were performed with the miScript PCR System Kit (Qiagen), using specific primers to miR15-a and miR16-1. Data were normalized to RNU6b expression and represented in an arbitrary units, with a log2 scale representation.
Genome-wide analysis of DNA methylation was performed by genomic methylated DNA immunoprecipitation, capture, and hybridization on Agilent Human CpG Island Microarrays as recommended by the supplier (Agilent Technologies).
Sequence analysis. The entire CHK1 open reading frame was sequenced on both strands. PCR was performed on 50 ng genomic DNA with Taq polymerase (Sigma-Aldrich), and the products were sequenced using the BigDye Terminator Cycle Sequencing Kit (Applied Biosystems). PCR primer sequences are listed in Supplemental Figure 7B. TP53 status was analyzed by direct DNA sequencing and functional analysis of separated alleles in yeast using the FASAY method as described previously (57).
Statistics. Statistical analyses were performed using the 2-tailed non-parametric Wilcoxon test. P values of less than 0.05 and less than 0.001 were considered as significant.
View Supplemental data
We thank the FA patients and families, the Association Française pour la Maladie de Fanconi, and physicians who referred patients to our center. We thank Anthony Lauge for contribution to the FA-associated gene mutation data analysis, François Plassa for the P53 FASAY test, Salvatore Spicuglia and Jinsong Jia for DNA methylation analysis, Daniela Geromin at the Tumorotheque of Hospital Saint-Louis (APHP, Pole de Biologie), and Hugues de Thé, Michel Lanotte, Emmanuelle Clappier, and François Sigaux for helpful discussion. Our center is supported by the French Government (Direction de l’Hospitalisation et de l’Organisation des Soins) as Centre de Référence Maladies Rares “Aplasies médullaires constitutionnelles” (to G. Socié) and by the “Réseau INCa des Maladies Cassantes de l’ADN” (to D. Stoppa-Lyonnet and A. Sarasin). This work was supported by a grant from PHRC AOM05066 “Diagnostic de la maladie de Fanconi” and a grant from the Agence Nationale de le Recherche (ANR), GENOPAT ANR-08-GENO-013-03. R. Ceccaldi has a fellowship from the Association pour la Recherche sur le Cancer.
Conflict of interest: The authors have declared that no conflict of interest exists.
Citation for this article:J Clin Invest. 2011;121(1):184–194. doi:10.1172/JCI43836.
See the related Commentary beginning on page 27.
Hartwell LH, Weinert TA. Checkpoints: controls that ensure the order of cell cycle events. Science. 1989;246(4930):629–634.
Zhou BB, Elledge SJ. The DNA damage response: putting checkpoints in perspective. Nature. 2000;408(6811):433–439.
Jackson SP, Bartek J. The DNA-damage response in human biology and disease. Nature. 2009;461(7267):1071–1078.
Kastan MB, Bartek J. Cell-cycle checkpoints and cancer. Nature. 2004;432(7015):316–323.
Bartek J, Lukas J. Chk1 and Chk2 kinases in checkpoint control and cancer. Cancer Cell. 2003;3(5):421–429.
Bartkova J, et al. DNA damage response as a candidate anti-cancer barrier in early human tumorigenesis. Nature. 2005;434(7035):864–870.
Gorgoulis VG, et al. Activation of the DNA damage checkpoint and genomic instability in human precancerous lesions. Nature. 2005;434(7035):907–913.
Halazonetis TD, Gorgoulis VG, Bartek J. An oncogene-induced DNA damage model for cancer development. Science. 2008;319(5868):1352–1355.
de Winter JP, Joenje H. The genetic and molecular basis of Fanconi anemia. Mutat Res. 2009;668(1–2):11–19.
Moldovan GL, D’Andrea AD. How the fanconi anemia pathway guards the genome. Annu Rev Genet. 2009;43:223–249.
Garcia-Higuera I, et al. Interaction of the Fanconi anemia proteins and BRCA1 in a common pathway. Mol Cell. 2001;7(2):249–262.
Auerbach AD. Fanconi anemia and its diagnosis. Mutat Res. 2009;668(1–2):4–10.
Shimamura A, Alter BP. Pathophysiology and management of inherited bone marrow failure syndromes. Blood Rev. 2010;24(3):101–122.
Kutler DI, et al. A 20-year perspective on the International Fanconi Anemia Registry (IFAR). Blood. 2003;101(4):1249–1256.
Rosenberg PS, Socie G, Alter BP, Gluckman E. Risk of head and neck squamous cell cancer and death in patients with Fanconi anemia who did and did not receive transplants. Blood. 2005;105(1):67–73.
D’Andrea AD. Susceptibility pathways in Fanconi’s anemia and breast cancer. N Engl J Med. 2010;362(20):1909–1919.
Seyschab H, et al. Comparative evaluation of diepoxybutane sensitivity and cell cycle blockage in the diagnosis of Fanconi anemia. Blood. 1995;85(8):2233–2237.
Heinrich MC, et al. DNA cross-linker-induced G2/M arrest in group C Fanconi anemia lymphoblasts reflects normal checkpoint function. Blood. 1998;91(1):275–287.
Akkari YM, Bateman RL, Reifsteck CA, D’Andrea AD, Olson SB, Grompe M. The 4N cell cycle delay in Fanconi anemia reflects growth arrest in late S phase. Mol Genet Metab. 2001;74(4):403–412.
Kruyt FA, Dijkmans LM, van den Berg TK, Joenje H. Fanconi anemia genes act to suppress a cross-linker-inducible p53-independent apoptosis pathway in lymphoblastoid cell lines. Blood. 1996;87(3):938–948.
Kupfer GM, D’Andrea AD. The effect of the Fanconi anemia polypeptide, FAC, upon p53 induction and G2 checkpoint regulation. Blood. 1996;88(3):1019–1025.
Rani R, Li J, Pang Q. Differential p53 engagement in response to oxidative and oncogenic stresses in Fanconi anemia mice. Cancer Res. 2008;68(23):9693–9702.
Lo Ten Foe JR, et al. Somatic mosaicism in Fanconi anemia: molecular basis and clinical significance. Eur J Hum Genet. 1997;5(3):137–148.
Waisfisz Q, et al. Spontaneous functional correction of homozygous fanconi anaemia alleles reveals novel mechanistic basis for reverse mosaicism. Nat Genet. 1999;22(4):379–383.
Gross M, et al. Reverse mosaicism in Fanconi anemia: natural gene therapy via molecular self-correction. Cytogenet Genome Res. 2002;98(2–3):126–135.
Soulier J, et al. Detection of somatic mosaicism and classification of Fanconi anemia patients by analysis of the FA/BRCA pathway. Blood. 2005;105(3):1329–1336.
Ikeda H, et al. Genetic reversion in an acute myelogenous leukemia cell line from a Fanconi anemia patient with biallelic mutations in BRCA2. Cancer Res. 2003;63(10):2688–2694.
Kaufmann WK, Levedakou EN, Grady HL, Paules RS, Stein GH. Attenuation of G2 checkpoint function precedes human cell immortalization. Cancer Res. 1995;55(1):7–11.
Neveling K, Endt D, Hoehn H, Schindler D. Genotype-phenotype correlations in Fanconi anemia. Mutat Res. 2009;668(1-2):73–91.
Klein U, et al. The DLEU2/miR-15a/16-1 cluster controls B cell proliferation and its deletion leads to chronic lymphocytic leukemia. Cancer Cell. 2010;17(1):28–40.
Lukas C, et al. DNA damage-activated kinase Chk2 is independent of proliferation or differentiation yet correlates with tissue biology. Cancer Res. 2001;61(13):4990–4993.
Boehrer S, et al. Suppression of the DNA damage response in acute myeloid leukemia versus myelodysplastic syndrome. Oncogene. 2009;28(22):2205–2218.
Wagner JE, et al. Unrelated donor bone marrow transplantation for the treatment of Fanconi anemia. Blood. 2007;109(5):2256–2262.
Pichierri P, Rosselli F. The DNA crosslink-induced S-phase checkpoint depends on ATR-CHK1 and ATR-NBS1-FANCD2 pathways. EMBO J. 2004;23(5):1178–1187.
Andreassen PR, D’Andrea AD, Taniguchi T. ATR couples FANCD2 monoubiquitination to the DNA-damage response. Genes Dev. 2004;18(16):1958–1963.
Guervilly JH, Mace-Aime G, Rosselli F. Loss of CHK1 function impedes DNA damage-induced FANCD2 monoubiquitination but normalizes the abnormal G2 arrest in Fanconi anemia. Hum Mol Genet. 2008;17(5):679–689.
Kramer A, et al. Centrosome-associated Chk1 prevents premature activation of cyclin-B-Cdk1 kinase. Nat Cell Biol. 2004;6(9):884–891.
Sorensen CS, et al. Chk1 regulates the S phase checkpoint by coupling the physiological turnover and ionizing radiation-induced accelerated proteolysis of Cdc25A. Cancer Cell. 2003;3(3):247–258.
Tonnies H, Huber S, Kuhl JS, Gerlach A, Ebell W, Neitzel H. Clonal chromosomal aberrations in bone marrow cells of Fanconi anemia patients: gains of the chromosomal segment 3q26q29 as an adverse risk factor. Blood. 2003;101(10):3872–3874.
Cioc AM, Wagner JE, MacMillan ML, DeFor T, Hirsch B. Diagnosis of myelodysplastic syndrome among a cohort of 119 patients with fanconi anemia: morphologic and cytogenetic characteristics. Am J Clin Pathol. 2010;133(1):92–100.
Maciejewski JP, Risitano A, Sloand EM, Nunez O, Young NS. Distinct clinical outcomes for cytogenetic abnormalities evolving from aplastic anemia. Blood. 2002;99(9):3129–3135.
Chen G, et al. Distinctive gene expression profiles of CD34 cells from patients with myelodysplastic syndrome characterized by specific chromosomal abnormalities. Blood. 2004;104(13):4210–4218.
Sloand EM, et al. CD34 cells from patients with trisomy 8 myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS) express early apoptotic markers but avoid programmed cell death by up-regulation of antiapoptotic proteins. Blood. 2007;109(6):2399–2405.
Pellagatti A, et al. Deregulated gene expression pathways in myelodysplastic syndrome hematopoietic stem cells. Leukemia. 2010;24(4):756–764.
Li J, et al. TNF-alpha induces leukemic clonal evolution ex vivo in Fanconi anemia group C murine stem cells. J Clin Invest. 2007;117(11):3283–3295.
Lengauer C, Kinzler KW, Vogelstein B. Genetic instabilities in human cancers. Nature. 1998;396(6712):643–649.
Haferlach C, Dicker F, Herholz H, Schnittger S, Kern W, Haferlach T. Mutations of the TP53 gene in acute myeloid leukemia are strongly associated with a complex aberrant karyotype. Leukemia. 2008;22(8):1539–1541.
Jiang H, et al. The combined status of ATM and p53 link tumor development with therapeutic response. Genes Dev. 2009;23(16):1895–1909.
Kennedy RD, D’Andrea AD. DNA repair pathways in clinical practice: lessons from pediatric cancer susceptibility syndromes. J Clin Oncol. 2006;24(23):3799–3808.
Farmer H, et al. Targeting the DNA repair defect in BRCA mutant cells as a therapeutic strategy. Nature. 2005;434(7035):917–921.
Bryant HE, et al. Specific killing of BRCA2-deficient tumours with inhibitors of poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase. Nature. 2005;434(7035):913–917.
Helleday T, Petermann E, Lundin C, Hodgson B, Sharma RA. DNA repair pathways as targets for cancer therapy. Nat Rev Cancer. 2008;8(3):193–204.
Chen CC, Kennedy RD, Sidi S, Look AT, D’Andrea A. CHK1 inhibition as a strategy for targeting Fanconi Anemia (FA) DNA repair pathway deficient tumors. Mol Cancer. 2009;8:24.
Shimamura A, et al. A novel diagnostic screen for defects in the Fanconi anemia pathway. Blood. 2002;100(13):4649–4654.
Pinto FO, et al. Diagnosis of Fanconi anemia in patients with bone marrow failure. Haematologica. 2009;94(4):487–495.
Chen GL, Prchal JT. X-linked clonality testing: interpretation and limitations. Blood. 2007;110(5):1411–1419.
Bertheau P, et al. Exquisite sensitivity of TP53 mutant and basal breast cancers to a dose-dense epirubicin-cyclophosphamide regimen. PLoS Med. 2007;4(3):e90.