Cell therapy trials for heart regeneration—lessons learned and future directions

P Menasché - Nature Reviews Cardiology, 2018 - nature.com
P Menasché
Nature Reviews Cardiology, 2018nature.com
The effects of cell therapy on heart regeneration in patients with chronic cardiomyopathy
have been assessed in several clinical trials. These trials can be categorized as those using
noncardiac stem cells, including mesenchymal stem cells, and those using cardiac-
committed cells, including KIT+ cardiac stem cells, cardiosphere-derived cells, and
cardiovascular progenitor cells derived from embryonic stem cells. Although the safety of cell
therapies has been consistently reported, their efficacy remains more elusive. Nevertheless …
Abstract
The effects of cell therapy on heart regeneration in patients with chronic cardiomyopathy have been assessed in several clinical trials. These trials can be categorized as those using noncardiac stem cells, including mesenchymal stem cells, and those using cardiac-committed cells, including KIT+ cardiac stem cells, cardiosphere-derived cells, and cardiovascular progenitor cells derived from embryonic stem cells. Although the safety of cell therapies has been consistently reported, their efficacy remains more elusive. Nevertheless, several lessons have been learned that provide useful clues for future studies. This Review summarizes the main outcomes of these studies and draws some perspectives for future cell-based regenerative trials, which are largely based on the primary therapeutic target: remuscularization of chronic myocardial scars by exogenous cells or predominant use of these cells to activate host-associated repair pathways though paracrine signalling. In the first case, the study design should entail delivery of large numbers of cardiac-committed cells, supply of supportive noncardiac cells, and promotion of cell survival and appropriate coupling with endogenous cardiomyocytes. If the primary objective is to harness endogenous repair pathways, then the flexibility of cell type is greater. As the premise is that the transplanted cells need to engraft only transiently, the priority is to optimize their early retention and possibly to switch towards the sole administration of their secretome.
nature.com