To faithfully recreate the features of the human neurodegenerative disease spinocerebellar ataxia type 1 (SCA1) in the mouse, we targeted 154 CAG repeats into the endogenous mouse locus. Sca1^154Q/2Q mice developed a progressive neurological disorder that resembles human SCA1, featuring motor incoordination, cognitive deficits, wasting, and premature death, accompanied by Purkinje cell loss and age-related hippocampal synaptic dysfunction. Mutant ataxin-1 solubility varied with brain region, being most soluble in the neurons most vulnerable to degeneration. Solubility decreased overall as the mice aged; Purkinje cells, the most affected in SCA1, did not form aggregates of mutant protein until an advanced stage of disease. It appears that those neurons that cannot sequester the mutant protein efficiently and thereby curb its toxicity suffer the worst damage from polyglutamine-induced toxicity.