The production of mature cells necessitates that lineage-committed progenitor cells be constantly generated from multipotential progenitors. In addition, the ability to respond rapidly to physiologic stresses requires that the signals that regulate the maintenance of progenitor populations be coordinated with the signals that promote differentiation of progenitors. Here we examine the signals that are necessary for the maintenance of the BMP4-dependent stress erythropoiesis pathway. Our previous work demonstrated that BMP4, stem cell factor, and hypoxia act in concert to promote the expansion of a specialized population of stress erythroid progenitors in the spleen during the recovery from acute anemia. Our analysis shows that acute anemia leads to an almost complete mobilization of BMP4-responsive stress erythroid burst-forming units; therefore, new stress progenitors must be recruited to the spleen to replenish this system. We show that bone marrow cells can home to the spleen and, in response to a signal in the spleen microenvironment, Hedgehog, they develop into BMP4-responsive stress progenitors. Hedgehog induces the expression of BMP4, and together these 2 signals are required for the development of BMP4-responsive stress progenitors. These data demonstrate that the interplay between these 2 signals is crucial for maintenance of this stress response pathway.