Leptin efficacy was compared in obese and lean female CD-1 mice. Body weights in these 10- to 12-mo-old mice ranged from 29.7 to 62.0 g, and leptin levels correlated with body weight. Mice from the lean and obese ends of the weight distribution were treated with daily peripheral leptin injections (1–100 mg/kg) for a 33-day period. The half-maximal effective doses for weight loss and fat reduction were shifted 0.5–0.7 log to the right for obese mice. Leptin was less efficacious at low doses (1–3 mg/kg) in obese mice but equal to or more efficacious in obese than lean mice at high doses (30–100 mg/kg). Leptin’s initial effects on weight loss could be explained by appetite suppression in both groups, but its effects on fat reduction were greater in leptin-treated than pair-fed mice, particularly in the lean group. Leptin also prevented the elevations in serum corticosterone and ketones found in pair-fed lean mice. These data allow a quantitative comparison of leptin sensitivity in obese vs. lean CD-1 mice and suggest that in mice where obesity is a function of outbreeding and age, leptin sensitivity is moderately reduced. Furthermore, although appetite suppression has a clear role in leptin’s effects on body weight, leptin may also have specific effects on lipid metabolism and mobilization that are different from the metabolic compensations that normally occur with food deprivation.