Marked variations are seen in the clinical manifestations of hereditary elliptocytosis (HE). To define the cellular alteration(s) that best reflect the variable expression of the disease, we evaluated the pathobiologic features of red blood cells in a series of 18 patients with HE, 15 persons from six families with HE as a result of defects in spectrin, and 3 persons from one family with HE caused by partial or total deficiency of protein 4.1. We found that decreased cellular deformability is a distinguishing feature of red blood cells in all patients studied. Comparison of volume and hemoglobin content histograms of red blood cells and reticulocytes revealed that cell fragmentation is a feature of mature red blood cells. The extent of red blood cell fragmentation as reflected by increased percentage of microcytic red blood cells was the best indicator of the severity of hemolytic anemia. Furthermore, we found that the observed variations in cellular properties of HE red blood cells in different persons is the consequence of varying amounts of mutant protein assembled into the membrane. These findings enabled us to define the mechanistic basis for cellular changes in this red blood cell membrane disorder better and also to obtain insight into the cellular basis for variable clinical expression.