Objective: To determine whether the hyperdynamic phospholamban-knockout hearts are capable of withstanding a chronic aortic stenosis. Methods: The transverse section of the aorta was banded in phospholamban-knockout and their isogenic wild-type mice, which were followed with echocardiography in parallel, along with sham-operated mice, before and at 2.5, 5 and 10 weeks after surgery. Results: Cardiac decompensation was evidenced by the presence of lung congestion in some banded knockouts and wild-types, giving rise to a subset of non-failing and failing hearts within each group. The incidence of heart failure was not genotype-dependent but rather associated with higher heart rates before surgery. The development of left ventricular hypertrophy was similar between knockouts and wild-types and longitudinal assessment of end-diastolic dimension indicated progressive increases after banding, with a greater dilation in failing mice. Fractional shortening was reduced in failing knockouts and wild-types to a similar degree, with an earlier onset in the knockouts. In addition, fractional shortening was decreased in non-failing knockouts but not wild-types. Ejection times shortened after aortic banding particularly for failing hearts. Assessment of the SR Ca²⁺-ATPase protein levels indicated similar downregulation for failing knockouts and wild-types, while the phospholamban levels were not significantly altered in wild-types. Conclusion: The hyperdynamic phospholamban-knockout hearts are able to compensate against a sustained aortic stenosis similar to wild-types.