Pentameric IgM and dimeric IgA both contain disulfide bonds between cysteines located in the secretory tailpieces of the heavy chains. To compare the influences of the mu and alpha tailpieces on the polymeric structure, we have replaced amino acids in the tailpiece of the human mu-chain with amino acids found in the corresponding positions in the human alpha tailpiece. We show that an IgM with an alpha tailpiece (IgM L561H, Y562V, L566V, S569A, D570E, T571V, and A572D) as well as IgM L561H, Y562V, and IgM A572D have a size distribution similar to that of wild-type IgM. However, one IgM mutant with a mu/alpha hybrid tailpiece (IgM L566V, S569A, D570E, T571V, and A572D) is secreted as a mixture of mainly hexamers, pentamers, tetramers, and dimers. The tetramers and dimers are specifically formed and secreted at the expense of pentamers and hexamers; no alterations in polymerization or secretion rates were observed. We have also incorporated the mu, alpha, and hybrid mu/alpha tailpieces to a human IgG3 or IgGL309C mutant. The IgG-tailpiece mutants are poorly secreted, but the secreted fractions contain multimeric molecules. Each of the mutants that contain both the L309C mutation and a secretory tailpiece forms mainly hexamers; however, small differences in polymer distribution exist for the different tailpieces. Comparison of the influence of different tailpieces on IgM and IgG polymeric structures suggests that the function of a specific tailpiece is dependent on other parts of the heavy chain, which can vary for different isotypes.