In this study, we tested the hypothesis that factor XI (FXI) activation occurs in plasma following activation of the extrinsic pathway by thrombin-mediated feedback activation. We used two different assays: (i) a direct measurement of activated FXI by ELISA and (ii) a functional assay that follows the activation of the coagulation cascade in the presence or absence of a FXI inhibiting antibody by monitoring thrombin activity. We failed to detect any FXI activation or functional contribution to the activation of the coagulation cascade in platelet poor or platelet-rich plasma, when activation was initiated by thrombin or tissue factor. Additionally, we found that, in the absence of a contact system inhibitor during blood draw, contact activation of FXI can mistakenly appear as thrombin- or tissue-factor-dependent activation. Thus, activation of FXI by thrombin in solution or on the surface of activated platelets does not appear to play a significant role in a plasma environment. These results call for reevaluation of the physiological role of the contact activation system in blood coagulation.