Published in Volume
115, Issue 6
(June 1, 2005)J Clin Invest.
Copyright © 2005, American Society for Clinical Investigation
Antigen-specific CD4+ T cells drive airway smooth muscle remodeling in experimental asthma
1Meakins-Christie Laboratories and 2Department of Anatomy and Cell Biology, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Address correspondence to: J.G. Martin or E.D. Fixman, Meakins-Christie Laboratories, McGill University, 3626 Saint Urbain Street, Montreal, Quebec H2X 2P2, Canada. Phone: (514) 398-3864, ext. 00137; Fax: (514) 398-7483; E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org (J.G. Martin). Phone: (514) 398-3864, ext. 00140; Fax: (514) 398-7483; email@example.com (E.D. Fixman).
First published May 1, 2005
Submitted: August 4,
2003; Accepted: March 16,
Airway smooth muscle (ASM) growth contributes to the mechanism of airway hyperresponsiveness in asthma. Here we demonstrate that CD4+ T cells, central to chronic airway inflammation, drive ASM remodeling in experimental asthma. Adoptive transfer of CD4+ T cells from sensitized rats induced an increase in proliferation and inhibition of apoptosis of airway myocytes in naive recipients upon repeated antigen challenge, which resulted in an increase in ASM mass. Genetically modified CD4+ T cells expressing enhanced GFP (EGFP) were localized by confocal microscopy in juxtaposition to ASM cells, which suggests that CD4+ T cells may modulate ASM cell function through direct cell-cell interaction in vivo. Coculture of antigen-stimulated CD4+ T cells with cell cycle–arrested ASM cells induced myocyte proliferation, dependent on T cell activation and direct T cell–myocyte contact. Reciprocally, direct cell contact prevented postactivation T cell apoptosis, which suggests receptor-mediated T cell–myocyte crosstalk. Overall, our data demonstrate that activated CD4+ T cells drive ASM remodeling in experimental asthma and suggest that a direct cell-cell interaction participates in CD4+ T cell regulation of myocyte turnover and induction of remodeling.
Asthma is a chronic inflammatory disorder of the airways that induces changes in airway structure, termed remodeling (1, 2). The changes include an increase in airway smooth muscle (ASM) mass, an increase in the size and number of mucous glands, and subepithelial fibrosis. The result is a thickened and hyperresponsive airway that gives rise to the clinical manifestations of asthma. Overall, the increase in ASM mass may be the main contributing factor to airway hyperresponsiveness (3, 4). CD4+ T cells with Th2 effector function play a pivotal role in the initiation and perpetuation of the inflammatory response in asthma (5–7). However, the relationship between airway inflammation and ASM remodeling is poorly understood.
A role for the T cell in ASM growth has been suggested by in vitro studies (8). However, the trafficking of antigen-specific CD4+ T cells to the ASM and their ability to induce remodeling in vivo have not been addressed. Although it has been possible to model the increase in ASM by allergic sensitization followed by repeated antigen challenge in the rat (9), the role of the T cell cannot be isolated in actively sensitized animals. Here, we employed the technique of adoptive transfer to test the hypothesis that antigen-specific CD4+ T cells drive ASM remodeling upon encountering antigen in vivo. Adoptive transfer of CD4+ T cells from sensitized rats mediates late allergic airway responses and eosinophilic inflammation in naive recipients upon antigen challenge, in the absence of specific immunoglobulins (10). In the present study, CD4+ T cells from OVA-sensitized rats were stimulated in vitro with OVA and subsequently transduced with recombinant retroviruses encoding enhanced GFP (EGFP). We exploited this stimulation and transduction protocol to generate a population of antigen-specific CD4+ T cells (11) that could also be localized in recipients. Our data demonstrate that following antigen challenge, these CD4+ T cells are localized in the vicinity of ASM or in actual contact with the myocytes. Moreover, adoptively transferred CD4+ T cells purified from OVA-sensitized donors regulate both proliferation and apoptosis of airway myocytes and induce an increase in ASM mass in an antigen-specific manner. In vitro, a crosstalk was established between cocultured CD4+ T cells and ASM cells in a cell-cell contact–dependent fashion. CD4+ T cells, activated by antigen, induced ASM cell DNA synthesis and proliferation only upon direct cell contact. Reciprocally, CD4+ T cell function was also affected by the cell contact, which prevented apoptosis of both activated and resting T cells.
Generation of antigen-specific, EGFP+/CD4+ T cells by sequential in vitro antigen stimulation and retroviral transduction. We performed in vitro antigen stimulation followed by retroviral transduction to generate a population of OVA-specific CD4+ T cells stably expressing EGFP in order to localize transduced, antigen-specific CD4+ T cells relative to ASM following antigen reexposure in vivo. Recombinant retroviruses transduce only dividing cells. Thus, following stimulation by antigen-presenting cells in vitro, antigen-specific CD4+ T cells undergo cell proliferation and are selectively transduced (11). These cells can then be identified and FACS sorted on the basis of transgene expression. Following culture of total lymph node cells from OVA-sensitized rats with OVA, and transduction with recombinant retroviruses encoding EGFP, an average of 7.9% of the live cells were EGFP+ (Figure 1A). The EGFP+ cell population consisted almost exclusively of live CD4+ T cells: 87.8% of the transduced cells were viable, as assessed by propidium iodide exclusion (Figure 1C), and 92.9% of the transduced cells were CD4+ (Figure 1E). The percentage of CD4+ T cells that constituted the lymph node cultures also was enriched by this stimulation protocol, increasing from 56.6% on day 1 to 90.7% by day 6 (Figure 1, B, D, and F), likely due to the combined effects of activation of antigen-specific CD4+ T cells and extensive death of other cell subsets. Significantly, the stimulated cells upregulated the expression of CD4 from days 3 to 6 as an effect of activation (12). This subset of CD4+ T cells is both selectively transduced (11) upon incubation with recombinant retroviruses and responsible for adoptive transfer of antigen-specific allergic responses (13).
CD4+ T cell activation, retroviral transduction, and adoptive transfer of inflammatory responses. Total cell populations from sensitized lymph nodes were cultured with OVA and subsequently transduced with retroviruses encoding EGFP. (A) We identified the transduced cell population using EGFP as a selectable marker. (C) The EGFP+ cells exclude propidium iodide (PI) and are thus viable. (E) The majority of the EGFP+ cells are CD4+ T cells, which demonstrates selective transduction of this cell type. (B, D, and F) Stimulation with OVA led to progressive enrichment of CD4+ T cells in the cultured population as well as upregulation of CD4 expression from day 1 to day 6 (compare B and D). The data from B and D are presented as histograms in F. The thin line represents the CD4 distribution in the lymph node cell population as harvested from donors on day 1. The thick line represents the CD4 distribution following lymph node culture with OVA for 6 days. The dotted line represents the isotype control. (G) Following transduction, EGFP+ cells were sorted by FACS, and 2 × 105 cells were transferred into unsensitized recipients that were subsequently airway challenged with OVA. Controls were recipients of EGFP+ cells challenged with vehicle or naive animals challenged with OVA. In recipients of EGFP+ cells, the absolute number of lung lymphocytes was increased 5-fold, and the absolute number of BAL leukocytes was increased 3-fold compared with controls. Data are from 2 independent experiments. Error bars represent range.
Adoptive transfer of small numbers of selected antigen-specific CD4+ T cells induces a robust inflammatory response with infiltration of the airway wall by activated CD4+ T cells. On day 6 of primary cell culture we sorted the EGFP+ cells by FACS and transferred 2 × 105 cells i.v. into unsensitized syngeneic rats. The recipient rats were challenged with aerosolized OVA or vehicle 24 hours prior to adoptive transfer, to enhance the recruitment of OVA-specific CD4+ T cells to the lungs, and rechallenged immediately following cell transfer. Forty-eight hours after transfer, total lung lymphocytes were quantified. In the recipients of EGFP+/CD4+ T cells challenged with OVA, the absolute lymphocyte numbers (range: 19.2 × 106 to 29.6 × 106 cells) averaged 5-fold greater than those of vehicle-challenged recipients or naive controls challenged with OVA (3.7 × 106 to 5.6 × 106 cells) (Figure 1G). In bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL), the amount of leukocyte infiltrate was 3-fold (range: 0.67 × 106 to 0.78 × 106 cells) greater than that of control animals (0.18 × 106 to 0.34 × 106 cells). By confocal microscopy, we localized CD4+ T cells expressing EGFP and the activation markers OX-40 and CD25 in the lungs. OX-40 (CD134) was first characterized in the rat as a specific marker of activated CD4+ T cells (14), and adoptive transfer experiments suggest that T cells expressing OX-40 may have recently encountered antigen in vivo, after transfer (15). On lung sections of the OVA-challenged recipients, we detected transduced and activated CD4+ T cells (Figure 2, A–E) in arteriolar walls, which suggests diapedesis; in the connective tissue bridging the vascular and airway walls; and infiltrating the airway wall, particularly the lamina propria. Significantly, EGFP+ and activated T cells were also located in contact with α-SMA–positive ASM bundles, with some labeled cells appearing to synapse with ASM cells (Figure 2 B–D). The confocal images colocalizing T cells with α-SMA–positive ASM represent optical sections of 0.6-μm thickness. Overall, this tissue distribution suggests that following antigen challenge, the transferred CD4+ T cells migrate from vessels into the airway wall, where they might regulate ASM function in a paracrine fashion and/or by direct cell-cell contact.
Confocal microscopy. (A–E) Distribution of EGFP+ (A–C), OX-40+ (D), and CD25+ (E) cells (red signal) relative to α-SMA (green signal). Insets in A and B show an overlay of the confocal sections over transmission histological images. (A) Example of an EGFP+ cell inside vascular smooth muscle (Vsm), likely exiting a small vessel (L, lumen). (B–D) Confocal colocalization in 0.6-μm-thick optical sections suggesting direct contact between EGFP+ (B and C) or OX-40+ (D) cells and ASM (Asm). adv, adventitia; alv, alveolar walls; E, bronchial epithelium. (E) A CD25+ cell likely migrating between a vessel and a neighboring airway. (F–H) Confocal extraction of ASM for quantitation. (F) In an airway, the smooth muscle bundles are identified by α-SMA immunostaining (red). The green signal corresponds to pan-actin (all actin isoforms), which was used as a general counterstain. (G) A high-magnification field (corresponding to the square in F) illustrates the airway epithelium, smooth muscle, adventitia, alveolar walls, and alveolar macrophages (mac). (H) The ASM bundles were isolated by confocal subtraction, to measure their surface area corrected by airway size. Scale bars: 100 μm (F and H); 50 μm (G); 20 μm (A and B); 10 μm (D and E); and 5 μm (C).
Antigen-specific CD4+ T cells drive an increase in ASM mass upon repeated antigen challenge. To determine whether CD4+ T cells were able to induce changes in the amount of ASM in an antigen-dependent fashion, we transferred purified CD4+ T cells from OVA- or sham-sensitized rats into unsensitized recipients, which were subsequently repeatedly airway challenged with aerosolized OVA or BSA. The transferred cell suspensions were obtained from donors by immunomagnetic negative selection and had at least 98% CD4+ T cell purity. Each recipient received 2 × 106 CD4+ T cells i.p. Following the CD4+ T cell transfer, the recipients were assigned to 3 study groups. In one group (OVA/OVA group; n = 8) the rats were challenged with aerosolized OVA at days 2, 5, and 8 after cell transfer. The rats assigned to the second group (OVA/BSA control group; n = 8) were challenged with aerosolized BSA at the same time points. Rats in an additional control group (sham/OVA group; n = 8), which received CD4+ T cells from sham-sensitized donors, were OVA challenged as described above. Twenty-four hours after the final airway challenge, we harvested and fixed the lungs. On lung sections, we localized by immunofluorescence the α-SMA–positive ASM bundles and subtracted this signal from the rest of the lung tissue using confocal microscopy (Figure 2, F–H). We then calculated ASM mass by quantitative image analysis. We expressed ASM mass as a dimensionless index that is derived from ASM area normalized for airway size using the basement membrane perimeter squared (PBM2). ASM mass was increased in the recipients of OVA-primed CD4+ T cells that were challenged with OVA (OVA/OVA group) compared with the OVA/BSA and sham/OVA control groups (Table 1 and Figure 3). These data indicate that: (a) the increase in ASM mass observed in the OVA/OVA group was driven by antigen-specific CD4+ T cells, since recipients of CD4+ T cells purified from sham-sensitized donors (sham/OVA group) did not develop this response upon challenge with OVA; and (b) the increase in ASM mass depended on the interaction between OVA-specific CD4+ T cells and OVA presented in the recipients, since CD4+ T cells transferred from OVA-sensitized donors did not lead to increased ASM mass upon BSA challenge.
Quantitation of ASM mass. (A) An increase of ASM mass was induced in the group receiving CD4+ T cells purified from OVA-sensitized donors followed by repeated airway challenge with aerosolized OVA (OVA/OVA group) compared with BSA-challenged controls (OVA/BSA group) or controls that received CD4+ T cells from sham-sensitized donors and were challenged with OVA (sham/OVA group). (B) The CD4+ T cell–driven increase in ASM mass affected small (PBM < 1 mm), medium, and large (PBM ≥ 2 mm) airways. *P < 0.05. Error bars represent SE. (C) Illustrative examples of ASM, once subtracted by confocal microscopy. Airways of 2 different sizes are shown for each group. The numbers below each panel correspond to basement membrane length and ASM mass (dimensionless index, ×10–3).
ASM mass and PCNA+ and TUNEL+ cell frequencies
The antigen-specific, CD4+ T cell–dependent increase in ASM mass is associated with increased myocyte proliferation and inhibition of baseline apoptosis. To investigate the mechanisms of the antigen-specific CD4+ T cell–driven increase in ASM mass, we quantified proliferation and apoptosis of airway structural cells in lung sections of the recipient animals. We detected cell proliferation in airway sections by immunostaining for proliferating cell–associated nuclear antigen (PCNA), a DNA polymerase-δ cofactor expressed in cells progressing through the cell cycle, the expression of which peaks during the DNA synthesis phase. Apoptotic cells were identified through in situ detection of DNA fragmentation by the TUNEL technique. To demonstrate proliferation or apoptosis of ASM cells, we colocalized PCNA- or TUNEL-positive nuclei with the cytoplasmic α-SMA staining of ASM bundles (Figure 4). We corrected the numbers of positive cells for airway size using PBM2 as was done for ASM mass. The number of PCNA+ cells per millimeter2 was significantly increased in the OVA/OVA group compared with the OVA/BSA and sham/OVA control groups, in both the airway epithelium and ASM (Table 1 and Figure 5A). This effect was present in small, medium, and large airways (Figure 5, B–C). The number of TUNEL+ cells per millimeter2 in the airway epithelium and ASM was significantly decreased in the OVA/OVA group compared with the OVA/BSA and sham/OVA groups (Table 1 and Figure 5D). This effect was also significant in the partial comparisons made according to airway size in both the epithelium and ASM (Figure 5, E–F). Together, our data suggest that increased proliferation and decreased apoptosis of ASM cells contributed to the ASM remodeling induced by antigen-specific CD4+ T cells.
Colocalization of PCNA and TUNEL with α-SMA. (A–D) Detection of proliferating cells (PCNA+, open arrowheads). (E–H) Detection of apoptotic cells (TUNEL+, filled arrowheads). Examples illustrating PCNA immunostaining and TUNEL, respectively, are shown for the OVA/BSA (A and E), sham/OVA (B and F), and OVA/OVA (C and G) groups. Both PCNA and TUNEL are shown as dark nuclear signals, colocalized with the α-SMA+ smooth muscle bundles (red cytoplasmic signal). D and H illustrate at high magnification the colocalization of PCNA and TUNEL, respectively, with α-SMA. PCNA+ and apoptotic cells can also be identified in the airway epithelium, in vascular smooth muscle of bronchial arterioles, and other locations as indicated. Counterstain: methyl green. Scale bars: 50 μm (A–C and E–G); 10 μm (D and H).
Quantitative morphology of cell proliferation and apoptosis in airways. (A and D) Mean PCNA+ and TUNEL+ cells per millimeter2, respectively, by experimental group. (B and E) Mean epithelial PCNA+ and TUNEL+ cells per millimeter2, respectively, by airway size and experimental group. (C and F) Mean epithelial PCNA+ and TUNEL+ cells per millimeter2, respectively, in ASM cells. Error bars represent SE. *P < 0.05, post-ANOVA; #statistically borderline difference with power less than 80%.
We used nonlinear regression analysis to fit a model of the increase in ASM mass as a dual function of increased myocyte proliferation and decreased apoptosis (Figure 6A). Details on the regression analysis are provided as supplemental material (available online with this article; doi:10.1172/JCI19711DS1). The possibility that a downregulation of myocyte apoptosis significantly determined the increase in ASM mass is supported by the fact that airway size had a dual effect (Figure 6B) on the size of the decrements of myocyte apoptosis frequency (exponential, r = –0.66; P = 0.0012) and the ASM mass increments (hyperbolic, r = –0.45; P < 0.0001) in the OVA/OVA group, whereas the airway size did not influence the increases in proliferation (P = 0.42). In the control groups, the relationship between ASM mass and PBM length was approximately flat (slope = –0.11), which suggests that the relative amount of ASM is a physiological constant along the bronchial tree in the rat (Figure 6B) and validates PBM2 as an appropriate normalization for airway size.
Regression analysis of the increase in ASM mass as a dual function of increased proliferation and decreased apoptosis of ASM cells. (A) Tri-variable projections and 3D reconstruction (a detailed split is shown in Supplemental Figure S1). The control groups were pooled and are represented as blue spheres for clarity. (B) Scatter plot of ASM mass (×10–3) versus airway size. The relative amount of ASM is approximately constant along the tracheobronchial tree (green and blue, OVA/BSA and sham/OVA groups, respectively). The CD4+ T cell–driven effect on ASM mass lifts and distorts this relationship (red, OVA/OVA group). The increase in ASM mass is greater the smaller the airways. The airway size also influences the effect on regulation of apoptosis; the size of the decrements in myocyte apoptosis frequency is greater the smaller the airways (TUNEL differential, right y axis, violet regression curve). The influence of the airway size on apoptosis inhibition and ASM mass followed similar regression trends, whereas there was no relationship between airway size and PCNA+ cell frequency (data not shown). BM, basement membrane.
Cell contact–dependent crosstalk between cultured ASM cells and CD4+ T cells activated by antigen induces ASM cell DNA synthesis and inhibits CD4+ T cell apoptosis. Next we tested in vitro the hypothesis, suggested by our in vivo cell tracking and confocal microscopy data, that a direct T cell–ASM cell contact mechanism participates in the induction of myocyte proliferation. We cocultured passage 1 cell cycle–arrested ASM cells with CD4+ T cells purified from OVA-sensitized donors that had been either activated with OVA in vitro or freshly harvested and added to the ASM cell cultures without prior activation. The activated CD4+ T cells were either allowed to establish direct cell-cell contact with the myocytes or cultured in the upper chamber of a Transwell system that prevents cell contact. After 48 hours of coculture, ASM cell proliferation was analyzed by flow cytometry on the basis of BrdU incorporation during the last 24 hours of coculture, as a cumulative measurement of DNA synthesis (Figure 7). Following trypsin treatment of the cocultures, the ASM cells and the myocyte-adherent fraction of the T cells were fully dissociated. The ASM cells were resolved from the CD4+ T cells by CD4 phenotyping combined with side-scatter profiling. Whereas baseline BrdU incorporation was 8.82% ± 1.45%, the addition of OVA-activated CD4+ T cells to confluent, cell cycle–arrested ASM cells induced DNA synthesis in 26.73% ± 5.32% of the myocytes only if direct cell contact was allowed (P = 0.001). Conversely, in Transwell cultures, where the activated T cells did not contact the ASM cells, BrdU incorporation into the ASM cells was significantly lower (7.48% ± 1.81%; P = 0.001) and did not differ from that at baseline (P = 0.778). In addition, only 10.02% ± 3.20% of the ASM cells incorporated BrdU when incubated with nonactivated CD4+ T cell in spite of direct T cell–myocyte contact (P = 0.007 vs. direct contact of activated T cells; P = 0.817 vs. baseline). The ability of activated CD4+ T cells to induce proliferation of ASM cells through direct contact was dose dependent (r = 0.99; P < 0.001; Figure 7E).
CD4+ T cells induce airway myocyte proliferation, dependent on T cell activation and direct T cell–myocyte contact. (A) Ninety-nine percent of the cells in primary ASM cell cultures expressed α-SMA. (B) CD4+ T cells (purity ≥ 98%) were cocultured with the ASM cells for 48 hours, in the presence of BrdU during the last 24 hours. Cells were immunostained for CD4, and BrdU incorporation by the ASM cells was quantified. (C) The CD4+ T cells and the smooth muscle cells (SMCs) were resolved with at least 99% specificity, as calculated from samples containing ASM cells only (upper plot) or T cells only recovered from Transwells (lower plot). In the lower plot, the left-shifted tail of the T cell population reflects some loss of CD4 expression from apoptosis. (D) BrdU incorporation by ASM cells. In each panel, BrdU incorporation is represented as a density plot (upper plots) and as a histogram (lower plots, thick line) overlaid on the baseline histogram (thin lines). The percentages of BrdU+ cells were calculated by subtraction. Myocytes incubated with 10% FBS served as a positive control for proliferation. The baseline BrdU incorporation was calculated from myocytes cultured in 0.5% FBS and 20 U/ml IL-2. The ASM cells were cocultured with: CD4+ T cells activated with OVA, either in direct contact (CD4+, OVA, direct) or separated by a Transwell membrane (CD4+, OVA, TransW); and with nonstimulated CD4+ T cells in direct contact (CD4+, no-OVA, direct). Coculture in direct contact with OVA-activated T cells elicited a significant increase in BrdU incorporation. (E) Dose-response curve of T cell effect on myocyte BrdU incorporation. Data normalized as percentage of baseline. n = 3–6 independent experiments per data point. *P < 0.05 versus baseline; #P < 0.05 versus Transwell and nonactivated T cells.
The analysis of BrdU incorporation versus DNA content in the CD4+ T cells cocultured with the ASM cells allowed us to distinguish several T cell subpopulations according to status of activation and viability, as determined by DNA synthesis and cell cycle analysis (Figure 8 and Table 2). Following activation by OVA in vitro and 48 hours of subsequent coculture with ASM cells, a fraction of the CD4+ T cells was progressing through the cell cycle and synthesized DNA. This T cell fraction comprised BrdU+ cells that were in S or G2/M phases of the cell cycle (region 2 in Figure 8 and Table 2) plus a subpopulation of live postmitotic cells (BrdU+ cells in G0/G1 phase of the cell cycle; region 3) and a subpopulation of cells that underwent postactivation apoptosis (BrdU+ cells with subdiploid DNA content; region 4). Another fraction of the CD4+ T cells, likely comprising non–OVA-specific T cells, did not incorporate BrdU and stayed quiescent (BrdU– cells in G0/G1 phase; region 1) or underwent apoptosis (BrdU– cells with subdiploid DNA content; region 5). In OVA-activated CD4+ T cells in direct contact with ASM cells, compared with T cells cultured in the Transwell chamber, postactivation apoptosis of the BrdU+ T cells as well as spontaneous apoptosis occurring in the BrdU– resting T cell fraction were prevented. Significantly, the proportion of live BrdU+ T cells was higher if the T cells were in contact with the ASM cells rather than separated from them, as those cultured in the Transwell chamber. These data suggest that OVA-activated CD4+ T cells in contact with ASM cells are selectively retained in a viable, proliferating compartment as a result of the downregulation of postactivation apoptosis. Moreover, direct contact of non–OVA-activated CD4+ T cells with ASM cells did not elicit progression through the T cell cycle, which suggests that the mere adhesion of CD4+ T cells to ASM cells does not result in T cell activation. Nevertheless, the apoptosis of nonactivated CD4+ T cells was prevented by adherence to ASM cells, as shown by comparison with the BrdU– fraction of T cells cultured in Transwells (Figure 8A, top left panel, region 5).
Inhibition of CD4+ T cell apoptosis by direct T cell–ASM cell contact indicates bidirectional crosstalk. Purified OVA-stimulated CD4+ T cells were cocultured for 48 hours with ASM cells either separated in Transwells or in direct contact. Additionally, CD4+ T cells were cocultured in contact with the ASM cells without prior stimulation in vitro. The cocultures were exposed to BrdU for 24 hours and the CD4+ T cells analyzed for BrdU incorporation and total cell DNA content. (A) BrdU versus DNA density plots shown with the corresponding DNA histograms. T cell BrdU incorporation plotted against DNA content defines the following regions: 1, live quiescent cells (absence of BrdU incorporation and in G0/G1 phase of the cell cycle); 2, cells undergoing proliferation (incorporation of BrdU and in S or G2/M phases of the cell cycle); 3, live postmitotic cells (incorporation of BrdU and again in G0/G1 phase of the cell cycle); 4, postactivation apoptotic cells (incorporation of BrdU and subdiploid DNA content); and 5, apoptotic quiescent cells (no BrdU incorporation and subdiploid DNA content). “A” in the DNA histograms corresponds to the subdiploid or sub-G0/G1 region and represents both quiescent and postactivation apoptotic T cells. M, cells in mitosis. (B) The corresponding side (SSC-H) versus forward (FSC-H) scatter dot plots are multicolor gated in the BrdU/DNA density plot regions defined in A. (C) Quantitative analysis of the cytometric regions defined in A and B. Data are from 4 independent experiments. *P < 0.05. Apop, apoptotic cells; incorp, incorporation.
CD4+ T cell proliferation and cell cycle following coculture with ASM cells
Overall, these data suggest that CD4+ T cells activated by antigen establish direct crosstalk with ASM cells, eliciting reciprocal effects. In a CD4+ T cell–ASM cell contact–dependent fashion, CD4+ T cells previously activated by antigen induce myocyte DNA synthesis and proliferation. Furthermore, direct contact with the ASM cells largely prevents apoptosis of the T cells, which may result in prolonged survival and expansion of CD4+ T cells following activation by antigen.
The data presented here support the idea that ASM remodeling, an important feature of asthma and airway hyperresponsiveness (3, 4, 16, 17), is driven by antigen-specific CD4+ T cells through a mechanism involving direct T cell–myocyte contact. We applied the methodology of Costa et al. (11), who demonstrated that a rare subpopulation of antigen-specific CD4+ T cells could be selectively transduced with recombinant retroviruses and subsequently sorted on the basis of transgene expression. We demonstrate here that relatively small numbers (2 × 105) of retrovirally transduced CD4+ T cells, when transferred back in vivo, migrate into the lungs and induce an amplified inflammatory response upon airway antigen challenge. This resulted in a spatial distribution of the adoptively transferred CD4+ T cells, which suggests that these cells may come into direct contact with the ASM in vivo. To quantify CD4+ T cell–driven ASM growth, we transferred purified CD4+ T cells from sensitized rats into unsensitized recipients. Previous work using this adoptive transfer model showed that the CD4+ T cells infiltrating the airways have a Th2 phenotype (18). Here, repeated airway challenge of the CD4+ T cell recipients resulted in an increase in the amount of ASM. This increase in ASM mass occurred in association with CD4+ T cell–dependent hyperplasia and inhibition of apoptosis of airway myocytes, which suggests that CD4+ T cells induce ASM remodeling by regulating myocyte proliferation and survival. Consistent with the confocal microscopy data suggesting direct contact between activated CD4+ T cells and ASM in vivo, results from experiments in vitro demonstrated CD4+ T cell–ASM cell crosstalk, which was dependent upon direct cell contact. CD4+ T cells activated by OVA, but not resting T cells, induced ASM cell proliferation through a mechanism in which direct T cell–myocyte contact was necessary, whereas soluble CD4+ T cell mediators were not sufficient if the activated CD4+ T cells and the ASM cells were separated by a Transwell membrane. As a reciprocal effect, direct contact with the myocytes prevented postactivation CD4+ T cell apoptosis and also the spontaneous apoptosis of resting T cells and resulted in significant retention of OVA-activated, proliferating CD4+ T cells in the live cell compartment.
In allergen-sensitized rats, repeated airway challenge leads to an increase in ASM mass (9) of comparable magnitude to our current results, and that is caused at least in part by hyperplasia, as shown by the induction of DNA synthesis in ASM cells (19–21). However, the pathways that link airway inflammation and remodeling of the ASM remain largely unknown. Human polyclonally activated T cells have been shown to adhere to ASM cells through integrins and CD44 and to induce myocyte DNA synthesis in vitro (8). In cultured ASM cells, the engagement of adhesion and immune receptors such as CD40, CD44, and VCAM-1 leads to signaling events that may be involved in proliferative responses including calcium mobilization (22), activation of MAPK and PI3K, and expression of cyclin D1 (23). In inflammatory bowel disease, where smooth muscle hyperplasia occurs in the muscularis mucosae, peripheral blood mononuclear cells interact with cultured muscularis mucosae myocytes through CD44 and VCAM-1 (24). CD4+ T cells may also contribute to other pathways regulating ASM cell proliferation and/or survival through their cytokines, either directly or via cytokine-induced release of growth mediators such as endothelin-1 (25) and cysteinyl-leukotrienes (20, 26) from bronchial epithelial cells or other cell types. Acting directly on the ASM, IL-13 may prime the myocytes to be more responsive to mitogenic stimuli (27, 28).
Our data demonstrate that antigen-specific CD4+ T cells regulate airway myocyte proliferation and apoptosis, which results in an increase in ASM mass. Furthermore, our experiments tracking genetically modified CD4+ T cells by confocal microscopy suggest that activated antigen-specific CD4+ T cells may interact directly with ASM cells in vivo. This is further supported by our data demonstrating bidirectional CD4+ T cell–myocyte crosstalk through direct contact in vitro. In a reciprocal fashion, OVA-activated CD4+ T cells induced proliferation of cell cycle–arrested ASM cells, and the ASM cells largely inhibited apoptosis of the OVA-activated T cells, which resulted in a significantly increased proportion of live, activated T cells. ASM cells may have a proinflammatory role in asthma through the secretion of cytokines (29). Our in vitro findings suggest another possibility, that CD4+ T cell–myocyte contact occurring in the airways may downregulate the activation-induced T cell apoptosis that limits cellular immune responses and thus contribute to the perpetuation of airway inflammation.
Our data support the hypothesis that CD4+ T cell–driven inhibition of myocyte apoptosis may be another pathway involved in the remodeling of ASM. Whereas there is a general consensus that apoptosis participates in homeostatic cell turnover in most tissue types, little is known about the mechanisms of induction and regulation of such apoptosis and its role in tissue repair. Normal airway (30) and vascular (31) smooth muscle cells constitutively express Fas and undergo apoptosis upon Fas cross-linking, which suggests that control of myocyte number through Fas ligation may be a general mechanism for smooth muscle homeostasis. A role of Fas and FasL has also been proposed in bronchial epithelial turnover (32). Stimuli promoting repair mechanisms in asthma may act as a switch that induces proliferation and inhibits apoptosis, favoring a prolonged survival of mesenchymal and epithelial cells. In our CD4+ T cell–driven experiments, the growth of ASM likely occurred as a combination of both proliferation and extension of cell survival. Regression analysis of our data suggested that the observed decrease in myocyte apoptosis may have contributed to the increased ASM mass to a greater extent than hyperplasia in this model. Although this argument is based on statistical inference, the data suggest a significant role for regulation of apoptosis by CD4+ T cells in the ASM remodeling mechanism. Further research is necessary to identify the pathways involved in the regulation of myocyte apoptosis by CD4+ T cell contact. This is not readily analyzable in a straightforward coculture model, since ASM cells isolated from the airways and grown in primary culture may lack mechanisms that drive their turnover in the ASM bundles in vivo. New models mimicking such mechanisms need to be developed.
In summary, adoptively transferred CD4+ T cells, labeled and selected for antigen specificity using retroviral transduction, induced an amplified inflammatory response in the airways following antigen challenge. Activated CD4+ T cells infiltrated the airway wall, where they may have acted on ASM through pathways involving direct CD4+ T cell–myocyte contact. Repeated allergen challenge induced a CD4+ T cell–dependent increase in ASM mass in vivo, which was associated with inhibition of apoptosis and increased proliferation of myocytes. In vitro, cell contact between activated CD4+ T cells and ASM cells led to reciprocal functional effects on cell cycle and survival, resulting in the induction of ASM cell proliferation and the reciprocal downregulation of T cell apoptosis. Our data support a direct contribution of activated CD4+ T cells to the mechanism of ASM remodeling in asthma.
Animals, sensitization, airway challenge, and lung processing. Inbred brown Norway rats (Harlan UK Ltd.) were sensitized s.c. with 1 mg of OVA (Sigma-Aldrich) adsorbed in 100 mg of aluminum hydroxide (EM Industries Inc.) and dissolved in PBS, and 0.5 × 109 heat-killed Bordetella pertussis bacilli i.p. (supplied by T. Issekutz, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada). For airway challenge, 5% aerosolized OVA or BSA was delivered through orotracheal intubation using a rodent pulmonary mechanics system (Quadra-T; SCIREQ Inc.). For lung processing, 2 mM EDTA/PBS was perfused through the right ventricle; BAL was collected through tracheostomy; the lungs were fixed at 25 cmH2O by tracheobronchial infusion of 4% paraformaldehyde/PBS or 10% formalin/PBS; and tissue sections were obtained in parahilar and midsagittal orientation. Alternatively, the lungs were digested in collagenase D (Roche Diagnostics Corp.) and lymphocytes separated by centrifugal gradient in Lympholyte-Rat (Cedarlane Laboratories Ltd.). The study protocol complied with the guidelines of the Canadian Council on Animal Care and was approved by the Animal Care Committee of McGill University.
Antibodies. Monoclonal antibody to retroviral Env protein (86A25) (33) was provided by L.H. Evans (National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, Hamilton, Montana, USA). We purchased mAb to GFP (JL-8), FITC-conjugated rat anti-mouse CD8 (Ly-2), and IgG1 isotype control from BD Biosciences; mAb anti-rat myeloid differentiation antigen CD172a (ED9) and FITC-labeled goat anti-mouse IgG, rat-adsorbed, from Serotec; mAb anti-rat B cell (OX33), mAb anti-rat CD8 (OX8), and mAb anti-rat CD4 (W3-25) from Cedarlane Laboratories Ltd.; magnetic microbeads conjugated to mAb anti-mouse IgG1 from Miltenyi Biotec; mAb to α-SMA (1A4) and rabbit polyclonal antibody to pan-actin from Sigma-Aldrich; Alexa 488–labeled goat anti-mouse IgG and goat anti-rabbit immunoglobulins from Invitrogen Corp.; mAb to PCNA (Ab-1) from Calbiochem; and biotinylated horse anti-mouse IgG, rat-adsorbed, from Vector Laboratories.
Generation of a stable retrovirus packaging cell line. To generate recombinant retrovirus, we used the Phoenix-Eco packaging cell line (purchased from American Type Culture Collection). Cells were maintained in DMEM containing 10% heat-inactivated FBS, 2mM glutamine, 100 U/ml penicillin, and 100 μg/ml streptomycin (Invitrogen Corp.). Cells were transfected using Lipofectamine-2000 Plus (Invitrogen Corp.), with pIRESPUR plasmid (0.5 μg) encoding puromycin resistance (BD Biosciences — Clontech) and pAP2 retrovector encoding EGFP (5 μg linearized with Fsp1) (provided by J. Galipeau, McGill University) (34). We subsequently selected successfully transfected cells by culturing in media containing 2 μg/ml puromycin (Sigma-Aldrich). We then sorted the puromycin-resistant Phoenix-Eco population by FACS to select EGFP+ cells expressing high levels of the retroviral gag/pol and env genes. We used for this purpose Ly-2 mAb to mouse CD8, which is coexpressed with gag/pol, and 86A25 mAb against Env protein. Retroviruses were titrated on NIH3T3 fibroblasts (ATCC).
CD4+ T cell stimulation and transduction. Cervical lymph node cell populations from OVA-sensitized rats were cultured at 5 × 106 cells/ml in complete DMEM supplemented with 50 μM 2-Mercaptoethanol (Fisher Scientific International Inc.), 1% nonessential amino acids (Invitrogen Corp.), 200 μg/ml OVA, and 10 U/ml of rat IL-2 (BD Biosciences). Following 48 hours of stimulation, the cells were transduced by spin infection twice at 455 g for 45 minutes at 37°C, with 6 μg/ml hexadimethrin bromide (Polybrene; Sigma-Aldrich), 10 U/ml rat IL-2 and approximately 106 virions/ml, providing a multiplicity of infection of 2. The EGFP+ cells were sorted by FACS on day 6 and transferred to recipients. For CD4+ T cell negative selection, lymph node populations were incubated with ED9, OX-33, and OX-8 mAbs, labeled with magnetic microbeads and passed through a depletion column (Miltenyi Biotec).
Measurement of ASM mass. Lung sections were coimmunostained with anti–α-SMA mAb (1A1), detected with Vector Red (Vector Laboratories), and polyclonal antibody to pan-actin, detected with Alexa 488. The airways were mapped with a confocal microscope (Axiovert 410; Zeiss) using a 20× objective lens and ASM extracted by channel subtraction. Vascular smooth muscle was then identified and eliminated with the aid of matched transmission images. We calculated ASM mass as ASM surface referenced to PBM2 for airway size correction using Image-Pro Plus software version 126.96.36.199 (MediaCybernetics). PBM is a constant dimension in an airway section, independent of whether the airway is constricted or relaxed (35).
In situ colocalization of proliferation and apoptosis with ASM cells. PCNA detection was preceded by high-temperature epitope unmasking in antigen retrieval solution (Vector Laboratories) and permeabilization in 0.2% Triton X-100 (Sigma-Aldrich). Sections were then blocked with 20% horse serum (Vector Laboratories) in universal blocking solution (DakoCytomation), and Ab-1 mAb to PCNA was detected with biotinylated horse anti-mouse IgG, avidin/biotin-alkaline phosphatase complex, and BCIP/NBT chromogen substrate (Vector Laboratories). Apoptosis was detected by TUNEL with an ApopTag peroxidase kit (Chemicon International) and enhanced DAB-Nickel (Vector Laboratories). Coimmunostaining with 1A4 mAb was developed with Vector Red and followed by methyl green (Sigma-Aldrich) counterstain. In cross-sectioned airways, PCNA+ or TUNEL+ cells were referenced to PBM2.
Primary ASM/CD4+ T cell cocultures and flow cytometric analysis of DNA synthesis and cell cycle. ASM cell cultures were prepared from OVA-sensitized rats as described previously (36) (see Supplemental Methods). The ASM cells were subcultured onto 6-well cell culture plates at a seeding density of 8 × 104 cells/well. When the cultures reached approximately 85% confluence by the third day of passage 1 subculture, the wells were washed 3 times with PBS, and the cells were placed in serum-free medium containing 0.2% BSA for 72 hours. At this point, the ASM cells were either stimulated with 10% FBS or incubated in DMEM:F12 containing 0.5% FBS in the absence or presence of CD4+ T cells. CD4+ T cells were purified by immunomagnetic negative selection from cervical lymph node cell populations that were harvested from the same rats and stimulated with OVA in vitro, as described above. Four million CD4+ T cells or a series of T cell numbers decreasing by 0.1 or 0.5 for dose-response titration, were added to each well of the serum-deprived ASM cell cultures, in DMEM:F12 (Invitrogen Corp.) media supplemented with 0.5% FBS. The activated CD4+ T cells were cultured either directly on the ASM cells or in the upper chamber of a Transwell Permeable Support (Corning Life Sciences). Alternatively, CD4+ T cells purified from freshly harvested lymph nodes were added to the ASM cell cultures without in vitro stimulation. To monitor ASM cell proliferation, we added BrdU (BD Biosciences) to the culture media at a 50-μM concentration for the last 24 hours of a 48-hour coculture period, at the end of which we collected the cells for analysis by trypsin treatment. The digestion with trypsin dissociated the adherent fraction of the CD4+ T cells from the ASM cells and produced mixed cell suspensions without doublets, as assessed by microscopy and flow cytometry. The cell suspensions were labeled with APC-anti-CD4 mAb and processed for the flow cytometric detection of incorporated BrdU and cell DNA content using an FITC-BrdU Flow Kit (BD Biosciences) according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
Statistical analysis. Data are expressed as mean ± SE unless otherwise indicated. Multiple comparisons were analyzed with 1-way ANOVA followed by post-ANOVA Fisher’s least significant difference test. The 95% confidence interval of the mean difference was calculated to estimate the size of effects in post-ANOVA pairwise comparisons. Association patterns were explored by best-fit regression modeling. Strength of association is expressed by r or r2. A P value less than 0.05 was considered significant. Data analysis was performed with the SPSS statistical software package version 12.0 (SPSS Inc.) and the regression module of SigmaPlot 2000 version 6.00 (SYSTAT Software Inc.).
View Supplemental data
D. Ramos-Barbón is a recipient of a Canadian Institutes of Health Research/Canadian Lung Association (CIHR/Canadian Lung Association) fellowship. E.D. Fixman is a recipient of a salary award from the Fonds de la Recherche en Santé du Québec. This research was supported by operating funds from the CIHR (to Q.A. Hamid, J.G. Martin, and E.D. Fixman; MOP-36516 and MOP-64362) and a CIHR/AstraZeneca-Canada Rx&D Fellowship Award (to D. Ramos-Barbón). We wish to thank J. Galipeau and D. Jaalouk, of the Division of Hematology-Oncology, Lady Davis Institute for Medical Research, McGill University, for their assistance in the generation of stable retrovirus packaging cell lines and transduction techniques and for generously providing the pAP2 retrovector; and L.H. Evans for providing mAb against retroviral Env protein. D. Ramos-Barbón received the 2004 CIHR Young Investigators Forum in Circulatory and Respiratory Health Postdoctoral Award (Eldon R. Smith Award) and the 2004 European Respiratory Society Clinical Allergy and Immunology Award 1st prize (supported by GlaxoSmithKline) for this work.
Nonstandard abbreviations used: ASM, airway smooth muscle; BAL, bronchoalveolar lavage; EGFP, enhanced GFP; PBM, basement membrane perimeter; PCNA, proliferating cell–associated nuclear antigen.
Conflict of interest: The authors have declared that no conflict of interest exists.
Bousquet, J, Jeffery, PK, Busse, WW, Johnson, M, Vignola, AM. Asthma. From bronchoconstriction to airways inflammation and remodeling. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med. 2000. 161:1720-1745.
Elias, JA, et al. New insights into the pathogenesis of asthma. J. Clin. Invest. 2003. 111:291-297. doi:10.1172/JCI200317748.
James, AL, Pare, PD, Hogg, JC. The mechanics of airway narrowing in asthma. Am. Rev. Respir. Dis. 1989. 139:242-246.
Lambert, RK, Wiggs, BR, Kuwano, K, Hogg, JC, Pare, PD. Functional significance of increased airway smooth muscle in asthma and COPD. J. Appl. Physiol. 1993. 74:2771-2781.
Robinson, DS, et al. Predominant TH2-like bronchoalveolar T-lymphocyte population in atopic asthma. N. Engl. J. Med. 1992. 326:298-304.
Gavett, SH, et al. Interleukin 12 inhibits antigen-induced airway hyperresponsiveness, inflammation, and Th2 cytokine expression in mice. J. Exp. Med. 1995. 182:1527-1536.
Ying, S, et al. Expression of IL-4 and IL-5 mRNA and protein product by CD4+ and CD8+ T cells, eosinophils, and mast cells in bronchial biopsies obtained from atopic and nonatopic (intrinsic) asthmatics. J. Immunol. 1997. 158:3539-3544.
Lazaar, AL, et al. T lymphocytes adhere to airway smooth muscle cells via integrins and CD44 and induce smooth muscle cell DNA synthesis. J. Exp. Med. 1994. 180:807-816.
Sapienza, S, Du, T, Eidelman, DH, Wang, NS, Martin, JG. Structural changes in the airways of sensitized brown Norway rats after antigen challenge. Am. Rev. Respir. Dis. 1991. 144:423-427.
Watanabe, A, et al. Transfer of allergic airway responses with antigen-primed CD4+ but not CD8+ T cells in brown Norway rats. J. Clin. Invest. 1995. 96:1303-1310.
Costa, GL, et al. Targeting rare populations of murine antigen-specific T lymphocytes by retroviral transduction for potential application in gene therapy for autoimmune disease. J. Immunol. 2000. 164:3581-3590.
Ridgway, W, Fasso, M, Fathman, CG. Following antigen challenge, T cells up-regulate cell surface expression of CD4 in vitro and in vivo. J. Immunol. 1998. 161:714-720.
Wise, JT, Baginski, TJ, Mobley, JL. An adoptive transfer model of allergic lung inflammation in mice is mediated by CD4+CD62LlowCD25+ T cells. J. Immunol. 1999. 162:5592-5600.
Paterson, DJ, et al. Antigens of activated rat T lymphocytes including a molecule of 50,000 Mr detected only on CD4 positive T blasts. Mol. Immunol. 1987. 24:1281-1290.
Weinberg, AD, Wegmann, KW, Funatake, C, Whitham, RH. Blocking OX-40/OX-40 ligand interaction in vitro and in vivo leads to decreased T cell function and amelioration of experimental allergic encephalomyelitis. J. Immunol. 1999. 162:1818-1826.
Wiggs, BR, Moreno, R, Hogg, JC, Hilliam, C, Pare, PD. A model of the mechanics of airway narrowing. J. Appl. Physiol. 1990. 69:849-860.
Leigh, R, et al. Dysfunction and remodeling of the mouse airway persist after resolution of acute allergen-induced airway inflammation. Am. J. Respir. Cell Mol. Biol. 2002. 27:526-535.
Watanabe, A, et al. Adoptively transferred late allergic airway responses are associated with Th2-type cytokines in the rat. Am. J. Respir. Cell Mol. Biol. 1997. 16:69-74.
Panettieri (Jr), RA, Murray, RK, Eszterhas, AJ, Bilgen, G, Martin, JG. Repeated allergen inhalations induce DNA synthesis in airway smooth muscle and epithelial cells in vivo. Am. J. Physiol. 1998. 274:L417-L424.
Salmon, M, et al. Involvement of cysteinyl leukotrienes in airway smooth muscle cell DNA synthesis after repeated allergen exposure in sensitized Brown Norway rats. Br. J. Pharmacol. 1999. 127:1151-1158.
Salmon, M, Walsh, DA, Koto, H, Barnes, PJ, Chung, KF. Repeated allergen exposure of sensitized Brown-Norway rats induces airway cell DNA synthesis and remodelling. Eur. Respir. J. 1999. 14:633-641.
Lazaar, AL, et al. CD40-mediated signal transduction in human airway smooth muscle. J. Immunol. 1998. 161:3120-3127.
Lazaar, AL, Krymskaya, VP, Das, SK. VCAM-1 activates phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase and induces p120Cbl phosphorylation in human airway smooth muscle cells. J. Immunol. 2001. 166:155-161.
de La Motte, CA, Hascall, VC, Calabro, A, Yen-Lieberman, B, Strong, SA. Mononuclear leukocytes preferentially bind via CD44 to hyaluronan on human intestinal mucosal smooth muscle cells after virus infection or treatment with poly(I.C). J. Biol. Chem. 1999. 274:30747-30755.
Salmon, M, et al. Contribution of upregulated airway endothelin-1 expression to airway smooth muscle and epithelial cell DNA synthesis after repeated allergen exposure of sensitized Brown-Norway rats. Am. J. Respir. Cell Mol. Biol. 2000. 23:618-625.
Wang, CG, Du, T, Xu, LJ, Martin, JG. Role of leukotriene D4 in allergen-induced increases in airway smooth muscle in the rat. Am. Rev. Respir. Dis. 1993. 148:413-417.
Lee, JH, et al. Interleukin-13 induces dramatically different transcriptional programs in three human airway cell types. Am. J. Respir. Cell Mol. Biol. 2001. 25:474-485.
Zimmermann, N, et al. Dissection of experimental asthma with DNA microarray analysis identifies arginase in asthma pathogenesis. J. Clin. Invest. 2003. 111:1863-1874. doi:10.1172/JCI200317912.
Panettieri (Jr), RA. Airway smooth muscle: an immunomodulatory cell [review]. J. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 2002. 110(6 Suppl.):S269-S274.
Hamann, KJ, et al. Fas cross-linking induces apoptosis in human airway smooth muscle cells. Am. J. Physiol. Lung Cell Mol. Physiol. 2000. 278:L618-L624.
Geng, YJ, Henderson, LE, Levesque, EB, Muszynski, M, Libby, P. Fas is expressed in human atherosclerotic intima and promotes apoptosis of cytokine-primed human vascular smooth muscle cells. Arterioscler. Thromb. Vasc. Biol. 1997. 17:2200-2208.
Hamann, KJ, et al. Expression of Fas (CD95) and FasL (CD95L) in human airway epithelium. Am. J. Respir. Cell Mol. Biol. 1998. 19:537-542.
Evans, LH, Morrison, RP, Malik, FG, Portis, J, Britt, WJ. A neutralizable epitope common to the envelope glycoproteins of ecotropic, polytropic, xenotropic, and amphotropic murine leukemia viruses. J. Virol. 1990. 64:6176-6183.
Galipeau, J, et al. Vesicular stomatitis virus G pseudotyped retrovector mediates effective in vivo suicide gene delivery in experimental brain cancer. Cancer Res. 1999. 59:2384-2394.
James, AL, Hogg, JC, Dunn, LA, Pare, PD. The use of the internal perimeter to compare airway size and to calculate smooth muscle shortening. Am. Rev. Respir. Dis. 1988. 138:136-139.
Zacour, ME, Martin, JG. Enhanced growth response of airway smooth muscle in inbred rats with airway hyperresponsiveness. Am. J. Respir. Cell Mol. Biol. 1996. 15:590-599.